Ratings based on 13 Verified Reviews

They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.6 out of 5
100% of guests recommend
4.8 Room cleanliness
4.5 Service & staff
4.7 Room comfort
4.5 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
We double-checked.
5 out of 5
for Everyone
by A verified traveler from Northern California

Fabulous Time

Posted Jul 3, 2014
Pros: Everything
Cons: Did not experience anything negative
Location: We were at the resort for four nights and were not lacking for anything to do. Tortula by ferry is the only other place with activities near by.
I would recommend Peter Island Resort and Spa without hesitation. We had a wonderful experience in all, the setting, beach, resort, food and beverage, spa, special activities and the entire staff.
5 out of 5
for Everyone
by Tammy from Atlanta

Excellent resort hotel & spa

Posted Jun 13, 2014
The perfect resort & spa with beautiful views, excellent beaches, wonderful cuisine and exceptional hospitality! First class experience and highly recommend. Enjoyed the massage overlooking the beach, private dinner, Vitner's dinner, private cabana, & all day motor boat excursion & met some very nice people.
5 out of 5
for Everyone
by PT from new york, NY

one of the btter resorts in the area .

Posted May 26, 2014
Pros: great location, quite beaches
Cons: transport back and forth from tortilla could be more frequent
Location: sailing , snorkle
this is a tastefully built place, remote and very nice rooms are great and food and service are very good. in this area one of the better buys
4 out of 5
for Everyone
by Sean from Philadelphia

Beautiful Island.

Posted Apr 16, 2014
Pros: Cleanliness, views, activities that hotel creates.
Cons: Food. Service was great but they made many mistakes on requests and changes.
Location: Relax. Beach. Drink.
We stayed at Peter Island for the tail end of our 2 week trip. The island is beautiful and the grounds are very nice. The hotel staff is extremely accommodating but they screwed up things a few times. Not a big deal, but it did create a few issues. Food was good but not great and a little overpriced. Breakfast was good and so was lunch. Dinner was OK but very expensive. We are biased as we travel frequently for work in Philly and NYC which have the best restaurants around....we're spoiled. Overall it is a great place to stay and be completely taken care....and relax. We are 50/50 on going back but if we were an older couple we would definitely go back.
5 out of 5
for Couples
by Cat from Indiana

Perfect location to get away and relax

Posted Nov 20, 2013
Pros: Clean, nicely decorated. Loved the balcony had room to lounge. Staff was fabulous. Beaches were wonderful. Private atmosphere.
Cons: Wish we could've opened up the louvered windows that led to the balcony (boarded down) to get a good cross-breeze instead of having to use the AC.
This was the perfect location to get away from it all. We were able to relax with a good book on the beach which was beautiful. There were plenty of lounge chairs spread out to give privacy if you desired. We were able to snorkel right from Deadman's beach; stay to the left along the rocks for the best snorkeling. We also spent 3 different days at White Bay beach, gorgeous! Beautiful with just 6 "shelters" on the entire beach. Each shelter had 2 lounge chairs, 2 chairs and a table. There was drinking water, a fresh water shower and bathroom facilitates that were kept clean and nice. The snorkeling from the beach was great, but once again the best was along each end along the rocks. We saw rays, reef squid, eels, turtles and hundreds of juvenile fish among the colorful coral. The water was clear, warm and calm. The staff was so friendly and eager to make your stay the best it could be. The excursions were also good, although the sailing trip to The Baths were too rough and churned up to snorkel when we went so the captain took us to Cooper Island to snorkel after we'd seen the Baths, it gave us the best of both worlds. Also enjoyed the quick 2 hour snorkel trips to the Caves and the Islands, both locations I'd go see again as the snorkeling was fabulous. Overall a great vacation spot that I'd highly recommend. However, realize this is not for those who love the nightlife, stay on Tortola if that's what you want.
4 out of 5
for Everyone
by KIMBA from Boston

Far from maddening crowds...

Posted Nov 3, 2013
Pros: Rooms, staff, views, island beauty, beaches
Cons: Meal options
Location: Virgin Gorda, the Baths Norman Island, snorkeling the Caves and the Indians St Thomas, shopping Tortola, more restaurants including Pussers
This is a great place if you like quiet, feeling of isolation yet with many comforts and luxury. The beaches are great, the staff caters to many requests, and it is great getaway. The snorkeling is decent and not difficult. It is easy to get to other islands in the BVI from here. People seem to come back to this place for the views, beaches, relaxation, romance, and great staff. Many have worked on the island for years. The only real downside is the expense and food selection; consider getting the food plan as options are limited since there is only 1 restaurant open for dinner every night. There are 2 onsite but for dinner even though one is more formal and the other less so the choices are very similar. The other option is to eat hearty at breakfast and eat a late lunch at Deadman's Bar and Grill, which is better than Tradewinds the more formal restaurant or take the ferry and go to Tortola. All in all would recommend if you like quiet, no TVs and beautiful views with most of the comforts of home.
5 out of 5
for Business Travelers
by A verified traveler


Posted Jun 21, 2013 on Hotels.com
Excellent location, private beaches, delicious food, fantastic hotel staff. If you are looking for a getaway then this place is perfect. Not Ideal if you are looking to party, and nightlife etc. no shopping unless u leave the island.
5 out of 5
for Couples
by C+V from Atlanta, GA

perfect island getaway

Posted May 9, 2013 on Hotels.com
One of the best places for a vacation we have been to. We enjoyed the beauty of Peter Island, perfect beaches, excellent food and very nice staff. We were impressed how well the island is maintained. There are wind turbines, rain water irrigation systems and a desalination station for excellent drinking water. The ocean front rooms are ok but a little outdated. We actually preferred the ocean front room location at the harbor close to the bar and Tradewinds restaurant. Upper floors have the better views. Beach front junior suites are in better shape and offer more space we were told. They are closer to the beach restaurant and only a short walk to main resort. Of course you can always ask for a shuttle. They have several golf cart type shuttles and mini buses. The villas are very nice. We would consider to stay in one of the three villas if we were going with 3 or more couples and kids. Overall we liked the secluded feeling of the island with only a few rooms (32 ocean front rooms, a few beach front suites, plus three villas which seem to be rarely occupied). We were not sure about the extra cost for food and drinks at the time of booking. It is easy to spend $500 per day (for two) at the restaurants and bars - although we have to admit that the food was mostly excellent. Check out the 'all inclusive' offers which we unfortunately did not find on hotels.com.
3 out of 5
by JR

Lovely setting but dated facilities

Posted Feb 27, 2013 on Hotels.com
The island itself is wonderful. It's in a beautiful setting and there are a number of areas on the island to explore. That said, the facilities were very dated. The shower in our room was old and cracked and did not feel very clean. The doors to the patio were dark wood with small windows, and did not stay open. It was impossible to just enjoy the fresh air and view while you were inside. Only one restaurant is open each evening which gets pretty old if you were staying multiple nights. The beach restaurant had harsh lighting in the evening which took away from the romantic nature of the setting. I give the hotel high scores for Deadman's Beach but otherwise it just wasn't the luxury hotel that it bills itself as.
5 out of 5
for Everyone
by Mike from Franklin Lakes, New Jersey

Paradise found!

Posted Aug 26, 2012
Pros: Beautiful beaches and great food.
Cons: Nothing
Truly a wonderful experience! Beautiful beaches, helpful staff, amazing food and relaxing atmosphere. I stayed nine nights and thoroughly enjoyed each day. I couldn't expected a more enjoyable vacation.