If you want to know the best places to stay, why not ask the locals? One popular choice among local travelers is the 4-star Saturnia Tuscany Hotel, which has received an average rating of 4.74 out of 5 based on 23 guest reviews. Other hotels worth consideration include Petriolo SPA & Resort, with its average guest rating of 4.71; Lola Piccolo Hotel, with a rating of 4.2; and Borgo Magliano Resort, which scores 4.25. Locals also like to book rooms at Hotel La Caletta in Monte Argentario and Villaggio Le Querce.
Looking for someplace to stay with your family? Hotel Sole is rated highly by families, plus it scores an average of 4.22 out of 5. Featuring an average guest rating of 4, Baia d'Argento is also worth a look. A Point Porto Ercole Resort & Spa has an average rating of 5. Argentario Osa Village in Orbetello, Residenza Principina RTA, and La Terrazza di Castiglione are also family favorites.
If you don’t have much advance notice, take a look at the 4-star Grand Hotel Bastiani, a favorite among last-minute travelers and featuring an average guest rating of 4.38 out of 5. You can also try Hotel Tris, with an average guest rating of 4. Relais Ciavatta has a rating of 4.67 and Resort Villaggio Capalbio is rated 5. Rifugio da Giulia in Civitella Paganico and Residence Le Corti are other popular last-minute picks.