Historic Hotels in North Eleuthera from $1,050

"Our group had the best time! Such an incredible property with a fantastic host. Can’t wait to stay again!!"

"This is a beautiful hotel and it’s right on the beach, and the beach is exquisite. It’s very easy to walk or use a golf cart to explore the rest of the island, and it seems very safe. The food was fantastic and the staff was very friendly. I want to go back soon! "

"We loved the cottage on the beach! Having a golf cart to travel around the island was fun as was the kayak and paddle board for water sports. We appreciated the attention to detail in helping us with arrival and departure!"

"This was the most wonderful and unique rental we’ve ever stayed in. The view was incredible watching all the fish below while eating lunch on the wrap around deck. It was so incredibly clean and organized, very comfortable bed, cable tv everything you need in a kitchen for two. We cooked most our meals. we love to fish and there was fishing available below some days we never left. Highly recommended and we hope to be back again soon!"

"Excellent service at this property!"

"It’s a cool secluded experience away from the tech, hustle and bustle. Looking to completely disconnect, this is the solution. #hideaway"

"The staff were all kind, thoughtful, personable and friendly. Tiffany, the owner makes you feel like family! She is a wealth of information for local spots to explore. Great dining at the restaurant. Will definitely return! "

"My flight crew team has been coming here for nearly a decade. Utilizing the Valentines resort for crew accommodations, this resort is the best facility per price, especially during off peak time. "

"This property is breathtaking views if the sea and the pool plus the grounds are beautiful!! "