Ratings based on 171 Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.2 Room cleanliness
4.3 Service & staff
4.1 Room comfort
3.9 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
by Chris from Chicago
great hotel for relaxing on beach.
Posted Jan 7, 2013
We only stayed in Naples for 2 nights and this hotel perfectly suited our needs. The beach area was great and lunch was very good.
by Gabriel from Miami
is ok but not for the price
Posted Jan 3, 2013
Cons: in and old hotel with non renovation
this hotel is good but the price you pay is to much
Good location. Close to beaches and shopping
Posted Jan 13, 2013
Cons: The room and the food
Location: Right on the beach and just a short drive to downtown
Hotel just ok. Expected more for a Waldorf Astoria. Food not so good. Waiter even told us not to order a few things on the menu because they were so bad! Even what he recommended wasn't very good Staff was very friendly but the room needed some updating. Carpet was very stained and worn. We've been to Naples many times and have stayed at other hotels that were much better for the price.
by Sara from Oxford, UK
Amazing hotel in brilliant location
Posted Jan 6, 2013
Cons: Having to leave at the end of our stay
Location: Right on the beach in Naples
Edgewater Beach is right on the shoreline in a lovely part of Naples We had a suite with a kingsized bed, the facilities were wonderful and the views absolutely beautiful
by Valerie from Glasgow
Great hotel for everybody with a relaxed feel
Posted Jan 5, 2013
Pros: It's right on the beach and had a relaxed feel.
Cons: Hard to get parked on the weekend.
Location: First class
We had a 2 bedroom suite which was a really good size. Gulf view was a bit covered by the trees but not an issue for us. Room service was good and there was plenty of storage room for all our stuff.
by Kathy from Northville, MI, USA
Good start to vacation
Posted Jan 11, 2013
Pros: Beach, location
Cons: Weather that week
We have stayed here twice before and love the hotel
by Christy W
lovely, but expensive beach resort
Posted Jan 8, 2013 on Hotels.com
Location was terrific, as was beach and pool area. Room was very nice, huge, beach-front, but furniture was not comfortable. Coffee maker was one-cup design, which we do not like. Request for an actual coffee pot went unanswered, as did other requests, i.e. no one fixed the maintenance items we reported, maid service was not done when requested. Staff was friendly, but service was spotty. Valet was great. I expected more for the price we paid.
by Doug from Kentucky, USA
One of my favorite hotels
Posted Jan 8, 2013
Pros: My favorite thing about this hotel is the beautiful beach access and the heated pools
Cons: I don't like guest rooms where there are not doors to bathroom area.
Location: The hotel is perfectly located
My husband and I have stayed at the Edgewater Beach Hotel many times and cannot wait to return again. Very helpful staff, beach is beautiful, with comfortable chairs and umbrellas. I don't understand why the decorators put black-out liners on windows in living room area and not in bedrooms, though.
Posted Jan 25, 2013 on Hotels.com
by Phill from Connecticut, USA
Very pleasantly surprised
Posted Jan 20, 2013
Pros: Location on the beach
Cons: Variety on hotel dining menus
Location: Right on the beach, perfectly centrally located.
We'd read a lot of mixed reviews about the Edgewater so were anxious about our trip there. We had absolutely nothing to worry about. We stayed in the main building, in a renovated room. The accommodation was updated, clean and very comfortable. Yes, there were some minor glitches like a light bulb or two that didn't work and the lock on our balcony door that didn't fully work, but nothing like the horror stories we'd read. The staff were absolutely lovely, very friendly and helpful. The location was great, right on the beach with a great view of the sunset and a fantastic fire pit for after the sun went down.