Ratings based on 27 Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
3.4 Room cleanliness
3.1 Service & staff
3.5 Room comfort
2.9 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
Truly a wonderful New York experience!Posted Oct 21, 2013
Pros: Comfortable beds, kitchenette
I lived in NY 15-20 years ago. I loved that this afforded my daughter and friends a true NY experience rather than the sterility of a hotel chain. Plan to be back in a couple years when the next kid turns 14...
for Familiesby Kevin from UK
Very central, safe, shabby chicPosted Sep 3, 2013
Location: Central Park, Grand Central Station, Chrysler building, Rockefeller, Central Library, Bryant Park, Times Sq.
There are mixed reviews about this place. However, if you want a good central location in NYC, with lots of space (we were 6) and don't mind an older building and with it condition then this is perfect. I thought it was great just to walk to most of the central attractions in Manhatten
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
Great Location for a very old roomPosted Aug 28, 2013
Cons: All but the location
Location: Empire State B is a block away
The description is not real, the appartment is run my the Community Church of Manhattan. There is no staff or anybody to talk to. The building is very old and so they are the rooms. the Bathroom is minuscule and the facilities are too fragile to be used. Location is incredible so depends what is that you rank higher
for Everyoneby floyd from Glasgow, Glasgow City, UK
Value for money basic rooms in midtown ManhattanPosted Jul 21, 2013
Pros: Location and price
Cons: coffee maker didn't work and dirty towels were never removed
Location: short walk to subway, good food store and restaurants nearby
You get what you pay for and this is an acceptable value for money option for midtown manhattan. I stayed here with my two teenage sons for a week and it was absolutely fine. There is no lift, the upkeep of the flat is poor and the kitchen is adequate for making breakfast but for little else and the aircon is noisy but the location is great and safe, the flat is large and comfortable and reasonably well equipped (fridge freezer, hairdryer, gas stove, tv, plenty of towels and soap, phone for local calls). You have to pick the keys up from a doorman at 10 park avenue just around the corner when you arrive.
for Familiesby Rich V from Georgia
Posted Jul 13, 2013 on Hotels.com
Location great, no one on site to giv keys. Need to explain where to pick up keys.
Recommendedby Kelly from Denver, CO
Excellent locationPosted Jun 17, 2013 on Hotels.com
Excellent location if you are looking to be away from massive tourist hotels and want more of a neighborhood type of stay. Major attractions in walking distance, if you are someone who likes to walk. If you want to finish your day at a local, less crowded bar you can do that here. The room is exactly as described. Clean, spacious, an older building with character. The kitchen is updated while the bathroom is less so. Would definitely stay here again.
for Everyoneby Hairy from Brisbane QLD, Australia
Value for money and locationPosted May 26, 2013
Pros: VFM Location
Cons: noisy aircon
Location: 15 mins stroll to 5th Avenue, 25 mins to Times Square
Value for money and location was our requirement and that's what we got. We were on 5th floor with no elevator and lots of luggage - a pain on arrival, but we did know of that! Rooms were comfy, basic but plenty of space and VFM. The apartments are let via a church association and they allowed us to leave our luggage in the church for a few hours which was very useful. We left a note of minor niggles for which we were thanked ("if we know we can fix it"). Only real gripe was a very noisy aircon unit, which was noted.
Recommendedby Carrie from Concord, NC
Yankees weekendPosted Apr 30, 2013 on Hotels.com
We came up for a weekend of fun and Yankee games. The weather was perfect the area is wonderful and centrally located in Manhattan. Our group consisted of 2 families of 3 so we were looking for a large space. This worked well for us. If you're looking for a hotel with many amenities, services and a hotel employee to help you everytime you breath in exchange for a tip... This isn't it. If you're looking for a clean, adequate, seemingly safe, nicely located, large place to put your things and lay your head, that's NOT $1000 a night ...this works. We will be back as this trip is turning out to be an annual fun weekend in the city.
for Familiesby guest house off park from new york city
do not stay here!Posted Apr 25, 2013 on Hotels.com
worst experience ever! Heat in the building was centalized, so it was 85 degrees in our room-had to run the individual air units 24 hrs/day. One of the bed's box spring was broken; therefore had to have the children sleep ON THE FLOOR. The Tv Cable did not work; therefore had to spend the entire day and night out of the unit; since it didnt pay to come back to relax. And the hot water was touch n go. Since we were traveling with young children, it would have been hard to find another hotel. So we had to put up w/ it. As the trip planner, I cried the first night and then become the group's joke for the remaining of the trip.
Recommendedby Diane from Baltimore
Easy Mid-town accessPosted Apr 16, 2013 on Hotels.com
If you are on a budget and can walk stairs this is a fine hotel. We were in the "penthouse" up five flights, but were fine with it. We had a kitchenette with coffee & tea for morning but only decaf coffee and there were no cups or mugs for the coffee and no matches to light the stove. We made due with bowls of microwaved tea. This did not detract from our time in NY and I would stay there again and just remember a travel mug and a book of matches.