Ratings based on 5,473 Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.3 Room cleanliness
4.1 Service & staff
3.9 Room comfort
4.0 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
Short BreakPosted Mar 8, 2014
Pros: Having the Tick Tock Diner joined onto the Hotel,if bad weather outside,perfect for a bite to eat.
Location: Ideally situated for Times Square and the Empire State Building.
Awesome,everything within a small walk,Hotel very clean,and Staff very Helpful and Professional.
for Everyoneby heyyeh from Milwaukee
Now WyndhamPosted Mar 8, 2014
Pros: Nice West Side location
Cons: room size in NYC always could be bigger
Location: West Side location close to K-Town, Madison Square Garden, south of Times Square, off the ACE subway lines and Penn Station
New Yorker is now a Wyndham hotel. Ok room size for NYC hotel, a little bigger than the queen bed. Several elevators for fast elevator service. Nice to have free beverages, and replaced each day.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
Nice hotel near Penn Station.Posted Mar 7, 2014
Pros: Convenient location
Cons: Room renovations
Location: 2blocks from Penn Sta; walking dist to most Broadway venues; restaurants all around; short taxi rides to museums.
Convenient to train, to Broadway, easy taxi to museums/restaurants. Reasonable cost for NYC.
for Everyoneby Marisa from Ayrshire, Scotland
Great hotel, great location!Posted Mar 7, 2014
Pros: Location and cleanliness.
Cons: Bathroom could be updated, new shower and tiles etc but that said current condition wouldn't discourage me from staying again.
Location: As above
Second time staying here and would not hesitate to stay again. Hotel is in the perfect location for those travelling in from Newark airport as it sits directly above Penn Station. Due to proximity to Penn station you can access anywhere from the hotel's doorstep and as it located in Midtown you can take many a lovely walk up or downtown. Amenities wise the hotel has all you need for a city break, the rooms are you typically small as are most of the places in NY and the bathroom could be doing with some updating but all in all I can't complain as the room was spotless and the bed very comfy.
for Everyoneby Leigh from Glasgow
Great central location, close to Penn StationPosted Mar 6, 2014
The Hotel New Yorker on West 34th and 8th avenue is a fantastic place to stay in New York. Firstly it's close proximity to Penn Station make it ideal for travellers arriving from Newark. It is also ideal for attending events at Madison Square Garden and for department stores such as Macy's and JC Penneys, whilst the Empire State building is only 3 blocks east in 5th avenue. The Tick Tock diner located next door to the hotel and accessible via the hotel lobby was a great place for breakfast with friendly staff. The room was clean and presentable and all staff were very polite and respectful. Free WiFi came with our room rate and proved very useful. Typically in hotels this size (40 floors) waiting for elevators can be a pain but with 6 dedicated to floors under 20 and another 6 dedicated to floors between 20 and 40 we rarely waited longer than a minute. The hotel provided an airport shuttle service via a third party and also had a gym and business centre. The lobby was well staffed and clean. Overall I'd recommend the Hotel New Yorker to anyone looking to stay in New York for the first time or those more seasoned of visitors to Manhattan.
for Everyoneby Loramay from Madison, WI
Pleasantly surprisedPosted Mar 6, 2014
Pros: The art-deco decorating. The knowledeable consierge and friendly front desk staff. The energetic, busy feel of the lobby.
Cons: A double bed is not a queen sized bed. Website and front desk clerk assured we had a queen bed - it was a double.
Location: On the corner of 8th and 34th. Macy's, Penn Station, Burgers & Cupcakes diner, 5th Avenue, bus stops, subways.
A 3-night stay. The room and hotel was generally clean and comfortable. The staff was professional and polite. The room was larger than I expected from NYC, but no frig or coffee pot. The location was perfect - close to Penn Station, a moderate walk to 5th Avenue and plenty to see and places to eat right near by. The view was uninspired, but with so much to see outside, we didn't care. The street noise was muted on the 29th floor, it was positively soothing.
by A verified traveler
Nice location, horrible facilitiesPosted Mar 6, 2014
Cons: Furniture way too old, carpets were dirty.
Location: Great location.
The room was literally a 1.5mx1.5m square. Totally disappointing, we could barely fit in there with our bags inside.
for Everyoneby NM from Winnipeg, MB
Great location, Great hotel!Posted Mar 5, 2014
We had the pleasure of staying at the New Yorker Hotel for 4 nights. We were up on the 37th floor, which actually worked out nice because it was quiet being that high up. The hotel staff was very pleasant and we were checked in in no time. The location was the best part! Right beside MSG center, right beside the subway and a short walk to times square, empire state building and much much more! The only downside was the size of our room which had the bed and hardly room for our suitcases. It would have been nicer and more comfortable to have a larger size room, although we weren't there to spend time in the room. (we travel frequently to Europe and the small size was comparable to European hotels). Another downside was the door to our hotel room wasn't very well sealed, it let in bright light all night long from big cracks around the door. It was definitely a safe location and the tik tok dinner attached served wonderful breakfast!! Over the weekend the hotel staff made sure everyone going to the elevators had a key card and it was very secure. There was construction going on at and around the outside of the hotel but it didn't bother us or obstruct our view one bit! We would definitely stay here again!
for Everyoneby Kafylou from Somerset England
Mum & Daughter trip to NYCPosted Mar 5, 2014
Pros: Location, very welcoming reception area and staff
Cons: Tea/coffee facilities in room or vending machine on landings
Location: Empire State building, Times Sq, 5th Ave. Subway entrance on corner right outside for A C E trains. Good if your coming in from JFK and Newark.
Great stay at the New Yorker, my love for NYC has been restored.
for Everyoneby John from Alexandria, VA
Good basic room in great locationPosted Mar 5, 2014
I had several meetings scheduled in different places in Manhattan as well as a theater play.. The New Yorker Hotel was a good base for the weekend.