If you’d like to tap into some local knowledge, check out the 5-star Pestana Porto Santo Beach Resort & Spa - All Inclusive. Not only is it popular with local travelers, it's also received an average rating of 4.6 out of 5. Another hotel worth consideration is Hotel Vila Baleira Thalassa, with its average guest rating of 4. Locals also like to book rooms at Praia Dourada Hotel and the 4-star Hotel Porto Santo & Spa.
Traveling with family? The 4-star Torre Praia Hotel scores an average of 5 out of 5 and is particularly popular with folks traveling with their families. Featuring an average guest rating of 5, Paraiso Dourado is also worth a look.