I picked Casa do Amarelindo based on the NYT review, and it exceeded my expectations. Let me give you three reasons to go:
First, the physical property. Smack in the middle of charming and chaotic Pelourinho in Salvador, and it's an oasis of calm, tranquil beauty. Perfectly maintained, tastefully decorated, pleasingly air-conditioned. My room was #12, on the third floor, was stunning. A play on yellow and blue, with the largest bed I've ever seen in my life - literally 8' wide, covered in crisp white linens, and a stunning view of the Bahia de Todos os Santos from the balcony. The bathroom was huge, with a whole spa shower experience and bronze Bizzaza tiles.
Second, the staff. Even better than the physical location, the staff is amazing. Friendly to a fault, they always introduce themselves by name, and take the time to chat. Carlos at the front desk gave me the most thorough overview of the upper city that I could ever need - it served me for all three days. Rafa at the bar is a charmer - take him up on his offer to invent a caipirinha for you. You won't go wrong. And the breakfast waiter (I'm sorry, I don't remember his name) was unerringly attentive. And the handyman who tried valiantly to salvage my broken iPad, Obrigado!
Third: The food. Breakfast is amazing, and will keep you going all day. The scrambled eggs are moist and buttery. The jam is different every day. Breakfast will keep you going well past lunch.
GO!
GO!
GO!