Ratings based on 11 Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
3.5 Room cleanliness
3.6 Service & staff
2.8 Room comfort
3.0 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
for Business Travelersby rochelle
Posted Jul 9, 2013 on Hotels.com
for Overnight Stay Before Destinationby A verified traveler
A warm and dry place to stay during a ski trip.Posted Feb 19, 2013 on Hotels.com
There is nothing bad that makes me want to steer others away from Brundage Inn.
Not Recommendedby A verified traveler
Posted Sep 6, 2011 on Hotels.com
no on site restaurant (as stated in review), room small, bed hard, walls thin.
Recommendedby A verified traveler
You get what you pay for.Posted Aug 9, 2011 on Hotels.com
We decided to stay at the Brundage Inn because of its price and because it was one of the few places left with a room available. It is a quite charming place, but you get what you pay for. The bed was quite hard and the bed frame squeaked any time you moved, making it hard to get a good nights sleep. The Brundage Inn is also located just far enough out of town that the passing traffic makes much more noise due to their speed.
for Couplesby A verified traveler from Kuna, ID
not a happy camperPosted Feb 15, 2011
With our room located beneath the stairs with only mini blinds for privacy it left us awake and feeling like everyone could see our every move. Our room had smelled of faint barf and when we woke to no hot water for showers we were given the excuse that the heaters to our rooms used all the steam needed to heat the water. Loved the town not the motel. :(
Not Recommendedby A verified traveler from Orofino, ID
Don't try to sleep in room 110, unless they fix itPosted Feb 9, 2011 on Hotels.com
The worst night ever! Didn't sleep a wink because the old wood bed frame squeeked if you even breathed. They called the room a Suite, ha! It was as small as some closets I've been in and the second room WAS a closet, with two bunkbeds built into it! OMG!
for Familiesby Traveler from Boise, Idaho
Not Impressed - Will not ReturnPosted Aug 9, 2010
I booked a Balcony Suite with Full Kitchen & Loft room. The balcony suites are located on the lake side of the hotel (away from the highway). The unit I ended up receiving was NOT a balcony suite and faced the highway. There was no loft either. I checked in at 5:00pm and got the room keys, but didn't go to the room until around 10:00pm, so I didn't know until too late that we received the wrong room. The air conditioning hadn't been turned on at all so the room was very hot. The air conditioning units were very weak and only cooled the 3 feet around them, so I opened the windows which let in all the highway noise. There were no queen sized beds (one double and two twins - and one full sized futon). The double bed was hard and the pillows roughly as thin as a blanket. Between the highway noise and uncomfortable bed, I hardly slept all night. Then a group of folks met up right outside the hotel around 8:30am the following morning, and their cigarette smoke came in both the windows and the air conditioning units. We decided to just get going, but when we got to the car realized we left some items in the refridgerator. My husband went back to get them, but could not unlock the room door. It turns out it's been on the maintenance list for weeks, so they sent a maintenance person to look at it. He broke the key off in the lock and spent so much time fidgeting with it, we decided just to take a loss and replace the items left in the fridge.
Recommendedby A verified traveler from Waunakee, WI
Great valuePosted Oct 3, 2009
This hotel is a good value for the money. It's handy to McCall and is no-frills, but clean and the staff is friendly.
Not Recommendedby A verified traveler from San Francisco
Bad experiencePosted Aug 23, 2009 on Hotels.com
At checkin they wanted to photocopy my license and credit card - bad idea and probably illegal. The room smelled musty, the toilet seat and sink were broken, and there wasn't even a piece of soap in the bathroom - no amenities. The desk closed for the night around 7 PM making it impossible to receive phone calls. Wi-Fi was not working properly. I pre-paid for two nights so stuck it out. There was no maid service. High season and the place was almost empty.
Recommendedby A verified traveler
Very Cozy and QuaintPosted Nov 17, 2008 on Hotels.com
Perfect for a group to get out and ski, good with promos.