Barnum Island Vacations from $225

Shuttle available only for LaGuardia airport.

I’m honestly tempted to gatekeep this place because it’s such a gem. I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed my stay. The room was clean, spacious by NYC standards, and had a nice mid-to-modern vibe. The staff was great — attentive, kind, and fast. I requested room service and it happened quickly, and when I realized I was missing something from the room, they brought it right up with no issues. The on-property restaurant was amazing (truly delicious), and the front-of-house team was warm and on point the whole time. Overall, I don’t have a single complaint. they are doing an incredible job with customer service. Kudos to the entire team.

Room was fine. The wall decor was a bit strange and the bed was pretty hard. The staff was decently pleasant and helpful and the blow dryer was way better than the small ones some hotels leave ya. No major complaints.

Lovely staff. Incredible property. The hype is real. This is by far and away the nicest property we’ve stayed at in Manhattan in a long time.

I won’t stay here again as the exhaust vent in the bathroom was packed with large amounts of dust (mold), my TV didn’t work, the WiFi was ridiculously slow, and the plug for the coffee didn’t work. I did sleep well and it was quiet.