This was a perfect base for me to explore the India of my imagination. It's a sketchy area for sure but I experienced no problems whatsoever. Just use common sense travelers' precautions.
The hotel was on a main street ... busy, crowded, noisy, dirty ... but wonderful. My room was clean and a reasonable size, and I slept well in the bed. I was at the back of the hotel, so it was quiet. This isn't a luxury hotel, but it was just fine for me - I just wanted a nice, clean, comfortable place to sleep while I explored the area.
The front desk staff was excellent - very courteous and helpful. Thank you Sudhir for making my stay so pleasant!
He arranged a cab to take me back to the airport in the middle of the night. Cab is not included in the room rate, but it was reasonable Rs. 500. Someone else at the counter tried to upsell me to Rs 650, but don't go for it - all the cabs are air conditioned.