Find hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse, Bay Shore from $96

Discovering the top-rated hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse makes for an unforgettable getaway in Bay Shore, New York.Clegg's HotelClegg's Hotel offers a cozy 3-star retreat just a 58-minute walk from Fire Island Lighthouse, rated 8.0 by travelers. This charming hotel features a beautiful terrace, perfect for enjoying the fresh sea breeze. Guests can indulge in complimentary continental breakfast daily and explore nearby attractions such as a marina and a stunning white sand beach. Unique amenities include beach umbrellas and access to water activities like sailing and parasailing, ensuring a delightful stay for all.The Palms Hotel Fire IslandThe Palms Hotel Fire Island is a stylish 3.5-star hotel located a 62-minute walk from Fire Island Lighthouse, a review rating of 7.8 by travelers. This Art Deco hotel features a range of amenities, including a furnished balcony and a kitchenette for added convenience. Guests can enjoy daily buffet breakfast and beachfront access with cozy beach towels and sun loungers. Unique offerings such as boat tours and kayaking adventures make this hotel a fantastic choice for those looking to fully experience the coastal charm.

For families seeking a memorable getaway, these top-rated family-friendly hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse offer the perfect balance of comfort and fun.Clegg's HotelClegg's Hotel, a charming 3-star hotel located a scenic 58-minute walk from Fire Island Lighthouse, is ideal for families looking for comfort and convenience. This hotel features connecting rooms and onsite babysitting services, ensuring families have the support they need. Guests can enjoy a complimentary daily breakfast, relax on the terrace, or engage in fun activities like board games and storytelling with children. With a solid review rating of 8.0, it promises a delightful stay for families.The Palms Hotel Fire IslandThe Palms Hotel Fire Island stands just a 62-minute walk from Fire Island Lighthouse and boasts a 3.5-star rating with a review rating of 7.8. This family-friendly hotel offers convenient amenities such as kitchenettes in rooms and cribs at no extra charge, making it easy for families to prepare meals and care for little ones. Guests can savor a complimentary buffet breakfast and enjoy the nearby sandy beach and marina activities. With a welcoming atmosphere, it's a great choice for family fun and relaxation.

Discover hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse that not only provide comfort but also stunning views.Clegg's HotelClegg's Hotel is a cozy 3-star hotel located just a scenic 58-minute walk from Fire Island Lighthouse. With a travelers' rating of 8.0, it offers a charming terrace where travelers can unwind while enjoying sea views. The hotel features convenient amenities like free daily continental breakfast, air conditioning, and designer toiletries. Guests can also explore nearby waterfront activities such as boat tours and parasailing, making it a delightful stay for those looking to enjoy the coastal beauty.

For travelers seeking affordable accommodations near Fire Island Lighthouse, Clegg's Hotel is a fantastic choice that provides comfort and convenience.Clegg's HotelClegg's Hotel is a welcoming 3-star hotel located within a 58-minute walk from the Fire Island Lighthouse. With a review rating of 8.0, this hotel caters to families with amenities such as free daily breakfast, babysitting services, and children's games. Guests will also appreciate the free Wi-Fi and nearby beach access for a delightful stay. Additional offerings include a terrace, executive rooms, and quick access to local attractions like the marina and boardwalk.

For travelers seeking a pet-friendly stay near Fire Island Lighthouse, these hotels offer the perfect blend of comfort and convenience for you and your furry friends.The Palms Hotel Fire IslandThe Palms Hotel Fire Island is a welcoming 3.5-star hotel located just a 62-minute walk from Fire Island Lighthouse. This hotel is particularly great for travelers with pets, allowing dogs and providing amenities such as pet-friendly rooms and service animals. Guests can enjoy complimentary breakfast and relax on their furnished balconies. Additional features include free beach towels, access to nearby boat tours, and convenient kitchenettes in the rooms, making it ideal for longer stays. With a review rating of 7.8, this hotel combines comfort with a warm, inviting atmosphere.

To look for discounts on hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse, join [One Key™](US: https://www.expedia.com/welcome-one-key)—our free travel rewards program. One Key members always get our best prices and earn OneKeyCash™* on eligible bookings for every dollar spent. Another way to save is by bundling your hotel and flights together on Expedia.*Excludes taxes and fees. OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Expedia and other participating brands.