Ratings based on 401 Verified Reviews

They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.2 out of 5
87% of guests recommend
4.4 Room cleanliness
4.2 Service & staff
4.3 Room comfort
4.1 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4 out of 5
by A verified traveler from Melbourne FL.

Great location

Posted Jul 6, 2016
Pros: Very friendly helpful staff
Cons: Lighting in the bathroom was not good.
Location: Several good restaurants close by and numerous charters. And the Montauk Point Lighthouse Park is just a few minutes away.
Check in was easy but several other visitors wanted to change rooms but like us booked through Expedia and the staff said it was not possible. They put all of us who booked through a third party, at the end of a long hallway at the edge of the property. At least there was an exit door nearby and parking close by. But the room was nice with a nautical theme, huge soaking tub, robes, water, chocolates and we did have a partial water view.
3 out of 5
by A verified traveler from New York, NY

Mixed feelings

Posted Jun 29, 2016
I have mixed feelings about the MYC. I've stayed here many times before and I'll probably stay here again but not as my first option. I've been here for weddings and just for a few days away in Montauk. There's so much potential but the service is very inconsistent. I stayed 5 nights recently. When I arrived there was an odor to my room and I informed the front desk. They came and sprayed the room but it didn't really solve the problem. They said they didn't have comparable rooms. I did search online and it seemed like they did have upgrades they could have put us in but just didn't care to. The staff just doesn't seem to have time to help beyond check in and check out. This hotel is in a 4 star price but is ranked 3 stars on Expedia and it shows.
4 out of 5
by A verified traveler from Long Island

Great getaway

Posted May 23, 2016
Great hotel. Great location. Amazing views, so relaxing. The private patios looking out onto the lake and marina are just beautiful.
3 out of 5
by A verified traveler from new york

To cold of season

Posted May 4, 2016
Pros: Location in summer will be perfect.
Cons: Service
Its was a nice hotel but the timing was wrong time of year with places closed for the season.Had a room next a room with screaming toddlers not a weekend get away. The staff was not friendly at breakfast took to long to service for a milk with my coffee, that the coffee was cold in the insultated jug this time was no peak season it was off season.
4 out of 5
by Firoz A from Melville, NY

Posted Apr 26, 2016 on Hotels
Everything was goo dexcept they did not teell us that all o fthe activities listed would not be open until May (after our visit there). Including even cycling which is not water activity. I chose the hotel because of its listed activities.
3 out of 5
by Gautam

This traveler left a rating score only Posted Apr 26, 2016 on Hotels
4 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Posted Apr 26, 2016
Great, comfy, convenient but we could have used a microwave in the room
5 out of 5
by Marcia

This traveler left a rating score only Posted Apr 16, 2016 on Hotels
4 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Very confortable, staff is very professional

Posted Apr 5, 2016
I love the hotel, the staff is a very professional, the kitchen especially, they take such pride in the meals they prepare
5 out of 5
by Joseph

This traveler left a rating score only Posted Apr 3, 2016 on Hotels