Ratings based on 65 Verified Reviews

They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
2.8 out of 5
56% of guests recommend
2.7 Room cleanliness
3.1 Service & staff
2.5 Room comfort
2.5 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
3 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Einfaches, aber sauberes Hotel

Posted Mar 24, 2014
Stadthotel New York, da man eh den ganzen Tag unterwegs ist, reicht es zum Schlafen völlig aus. War absolut in Ordnung!
1 out of 5
by よしお


Posted Mar 20, 2014
Pros: 無し。
Cons: Everything.
Location: Brooklyn, Battery Park, Wall Street
3 out of 5
by flyby

Personel correct 4 jours sans eau ! Scandaleux

Posted Mar 18, 2014
Pros: Originalité.
Cons: Propreté, couverture, room service inexistant
Location: Top emplacement.
4jours sans eau chaude et parfois sans eau du tout ca peut arriver je comprend mais sans etre avisé, l hotel a fait un geste parceque j ai montrer mon mecontentement sinon rien a cirer... Aucun room service donc aucun menage pendant 1 semaine. J en veux un peu a expedia de ne pas l avoir precisé ou trop discretement...dommage , emplacement ideal .
1 out of 5
by Frank S. from Hamburg


Posted Mar 17, 2014 on Hotels
Ein dreckigeres Hotel habe ich noch nie gesehen. Hohe Staubschichten, versiffter Boden, eckliges Waschbecken. Obwohl wir 7 Übernachtungen hatten, gab es keinerlei Zimmerservice. Noch nicht einmal der Abfalleimer wurde geleert. Die Heizung ging trotz frostiger Temperaturen an manchen Tagen nicht. Zudem hat die Heizung ein Überdruckventil, das höllischen Lärm macht. An einem Tag gab es im Waschbecken und in der Dusche überhaupt kein Wasser, an anderen Tagen tröpfelte es zumindest. Von dem Hotel kann ich nur abraten. Einzig die Lage ist gut.
1 out of 5
by A verified traveler


Posted Mar 16, 2014
When i came here there wasn't no water!! The room is terrible, bed and pillows are old and very bad. Every day that i try to use the shower the water was not working or stopped in the middle and it didn't come back!! When you enter this hotel, you leave a first class country to enter the worst third row country you'll ever see. Come and visit it.
5 out of 5
by Laurens from Deurne

Leuk hotel midden in de stad.

Posted Mar 16, 2014
Pros: De schilderingen op de kamers
Cons: Niets. Is perfect zoals het is.
Location: Metro bereikbaar op twee en drie blokken afstand. Met mooi weer is het heerlijk toeven in Madison Square Park, drie blokken westwaarts.
Hotel is in alle vertrekken voorzien van kleurrijke schilderingen van echte kunstenaars. Misschien niet geschikt voor alle reizigers maar super voor de liefhebbers van kunst die niet te veel netheid verwachten.
3 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Zentral gelegen

Posted Mar 15, 2014
Eine Woche Städtetrip New York, viel unterwegs in der Stadt
3 out of 5
by ST from アメリカ留学中


Posted Mar 13, 2014
グランドセントラル駅やエンパイアステイトビルからも近く、立地はとてもよかったです。最寄りの地下鉄の駅からも近かったですよ。タイムズスクエアからタクシーを使ってもチップ入れて9ドルほどでした。 ただ建物は不思議な内装で、落ち着きませんでした。 最上階(確か4階?)までエレベーターはなく螺旋階段のような狭い階段をスーツケース片手に上っていかなければなりません。かなりきついです。 バストイレは共用でした。私は夜にシャワーを浴びていたので混み合うことはありませんでしたが、朝は結構混んでたように思います。 スタッフの方はとても優しくて、持ってきていなかったドライヤーなど貸してくれたのですが、内装や部屋の薄暗さ。締まりの悪い蛇口などなど、少し潔癖性な私にはどうしても落ち着ける場所にはなりませんでした。 ※ホテルで猫を飼っているようです。ホテル内をウロウロしていて、一度私の部屋に入ってきたことがありました。アレルギーなどお持ちの方は注意なさってください。
3 out of 5
by Sheri from Pleasantville

LOWER YOUR EXPECTATIONS....enjoy your stay!

Posted Mar 11, 2014
Pros: It was neat to "explore" the different floors and room motifs. It was not too expensive. Has a lot of "history". Not a bad area of New York City.
Cons: NO hot water, bed was NOT comfortable, NO blankets, NO mirror or sink in bathroom, toilet leaked all over floor, room was HOT(radiator). Fire trap!
Location: Not a bad area, working class neighborhood, nearby cafes, restaurants, bars, coffee shops, right next to Barruch College. Walking distance to subway.
We were looking for affordable accommodations in Manhattan...not easy to find. The Carlton Arms fits that description, BUT... don't expect anything resembling a "normal" hotel. If you look up ECLECTIC in the dictionary, you will see a picture of this place. This is quite an old building with each floor and room decorated differently. We had a room with 2 twin beds and private bathroom...not all rooms have bathrooms. Each floor has a community bathroom and shower, like a hostel. Two (friendly) cats roam free in the building. This place is old, dirty and WEIRD! We never felt unsafe in the neighborhood. If you know what you are getting yourself into, it's tolerable. STAYING HERE IS AN EXPERIENCE! It will give you a good story to tell your friends. . Stayed a couple nights...lived to tell about it.
3 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Billige und zentrale Absteige

Posted Mar 10, 2014
+ Preis ist unschlagbar, haben umgerechnet im Paket 50€ für das Zimmer pro Nacht gezahlt + gleich in der Nähe vom Empire State Building + Zimmer sind relativ sauber und geheizt (gut im Winter) - Lautstärke (man denkt man wohnt neben der Autobahn) - Fenster schloss nicht richtig, es zog dadurch ins Zimmer - Ausstattung ist aus den 50er Jahren, man hat das Gefühl es wurde noch nie was daran gemacht.