Ratings based on 251 Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.4 Room cleanliness
4.3 Service & staff
4.4 Room comfort
4.1 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from worcester
Top Hotel in New YorkPosted Sep 22, 2015
Superb Hotel in the very hart of New York, On the down side, other than in the rooms toilet facilities few and far between and difficult to find. On a personal note, it seems incredible that the management of such a prestigious Hotel should choose to have painting done during the day time resulting in damaged clothes and accessories
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Liverpool
Elegant Hotel.Posted Sep 14, 2015
Pros: Lobby is simply stunning. Bedrooms are spacious and light. Very relaxed atmosphere.
Cons: Service in the downstairs bar area could be better.
Location: Midtown Manhattan on your doorstep !!!
Fabulous hotel in central Manhattan. Ideally placed for Times Square and the 5th Avenue store. As soon as you walk through the door you can feel the history and sheer elegance of the hotel. Rooms are a little dated in comparison to modern hotel standards but not having a double sink or whirlpool bath is small comparison to the décor and history.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Glasgow, Scotland
Luxury in NewYorkPosted Sep 10, 2015
Pros: The sheer luxury of the surroundings and the helpful and friendly staff
Location: There is so much to see four days are just not long enough
From our arrival to our last day the staff were incredible. The room was spacious and clean and the facilities were second to none. If you want a special experience, look no further
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Bergamo
La storia nel nuovo mondoPosted Sep 8, 2015
Per me è il terzo soggiorno qui e quando tornerò a NY ci soggiornerò di nuovo, sicuramente!! La colazione all'Astoria Lounge e' abbondante e di ottima qualità. Due piccoli nei: - L'ice machine si trova solo al 17mo piano dell'Astoria - in camera non c'è la coffe maker Per il resto tutto positivo.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Naples, FL
Beautiful hotel close to some great shopping!!Posted Sep 8, 2015
Pros: Location Excellent staff Beautiful facility
Cons: The Astoria Lounge is in desperate need of improvement.
We enjoyed the proximity of the hotel to the places we visit most often while in New York. We stayed in the Towers and the staff was excellent. The front desk staff addressed us by name each time we walked by the desk. The room was comfortable and clean, but the bathroom had a little musty smell. The Astoria Lounge where breakfast is served was small, cramped and most always had a lengthy line of people waiting for a seat. The food was acceptable, but on most days they ran out of breakfast items early and would not replenish anything. While we were there they ran out of oatmeal each day at least an hour before breakfast ended. Though several people asked, they said they would not be making anymore. One day they ran out of coffee. I strongly feel that a hotel of this quality should not only have a much larger space to serve the guests in the Towers, but they also should not ever run out of food before the listed ending time for breakfast.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Roma
Storico albergo New yorkesePosted Sep 2, 2015
L'albergo ti accoglie con il suo profumo inconfondibile misto di fiori e di antico. Il personale è professionale e gentilissimo. È un 5 stelle ovviamente. La stanza è molto accogliente, soffitti alti e dotate di due letti alla francese , molto confortevoli. Unico neo il bagno piccolo e non proprio bello. Ma devo dire che la nostra cameriera di piano ci ha coccolato per tutto il soggiorno che è stato di 10 giorni. Tutte le sere faceva il riassetto serale non facendoci mancare nulla. Nella lounge sempre cortesi e buone colazioni e lunch. Nelle mattine di punta con tanta gente in fila ci hanno offerto l colazione al ristorante al piano terra dove la colazione era superlativa. Consiglierei al hotel un riaggiornamento dei bagni e un potenziamento dei servizi del fitness tipo sauna e idromassaggio che sono mancanti.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from H
Très bel hôtel New Yorkais, très bien situéPosted Aug 31, 2015
Nous avons eu un très bel et excellent voyage de noces !
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Florida
Posted Aug 27, 2015
Great hotel....the hop on hop off bus stops right around the corner.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
Old fashioned beauty with original fittingsPosted Aug 24, 2015
I have read a lot of negative reviews so was pleasantly surprised at my experience. The rooms are not modern but they are full of class and quality no chipboard here. The lights were gorgeous and ceilings high. The rooms were clean and well maintained. If you want some old world charm please do stay here. The downstairs was like no other with bars and intimate corners to sit and relax. Staff were great too. There is turn down service. We had room 36F2 which was a few rooms so recommend this. Nice touch was that the afternoon tea was included with breakfast and was really delicious.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
Sehr zentrale Lage in Midtown ManhattanPosted Aug 24, 2015
Altes aber gutes Hotel in sehr zentraler Lage in Midtown Manhattan. Alles leicht zu Fuss erreichbar, Empire, Rockefeller Center, MoMA usw. Schöne Bars, sehr nettes Personal. Ich gehe wieder hin.