Ratings based on 40 Verified Reviews
4.9 Room cleanliness
4.9 Service & staff
4.6 Room comfort
4.8 Hotel condition
Expedia Verified Reviews
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Williamsport PA
A weekend on the Fall Harvest Wine TourPosted Sep 22, 2017
Pros: Spacious rooms, Quiet neighborhood. Great hosts.
Location: Many wineries and restaurants within a very short distance.
We had a great stay at the Finger Lakes Bed and Breakfast. Casey and Cindy are perfect hosts. The location is really quite good for touring the wine country. Penn Yan is at the northern end of Keuka Lake and there are a fairly good amount of wineries within a short drive. The B&B is a wonderful 1840s era home, with spacious rooms. Breakfast is just the right amount and tastes fantastic.
Posted Apr 19, 2017 on Hotels
We loved staying at the Finger Lakes B&B! Our hosts, Cindy and Casey were fabulous! Our room was clean and comfortable. Breakfast was abundant and delicious! We will be back!
Best B&B I've ever stayed inPosted Feb 21, 2017 on Hotels
Staff was beyond friendly and welcoming. Water pressure was amazing (hard to find in commercial places). Breakfast was cooked differently each morning which was very nice. Location is GREAT. 5 mins to Keuka and 10-15 mins to Seneca.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Toronto
Nice BnB in lovely areaPosted Nov 18, 2016
This is an older house kept in good condition by the wonderful owners, Casey and Cindy. Therefore, it had large rooms and high ceilings and plenty of books if you wanted to stay indoors. The bedroom was a bit on the small side, but the bed was comfortable. Nice having our own ensuite bathroom. Breakfast was a treat, beautifully presented and cooked. If we're in the area again, we'll be back!
for Couplesby A verified traveler from Cleveland, Ohio
Quiet ComfortPosted Sep 24, 2016
Pros: Very quiet and comfortable. Slept vert\y well.
Location: A myriad of things to keep busy over a long weekend. It's a beautiful area.
The couple running the place were great, very warm but not intrusive. Were very knowledgable on local sites and activities. they gave us some very good recommendations.
by Georgina from Port Saint Lucie
Hidden GemPosted Aug 1, 2016 on Hotels
This B&B is centrally located in Penn Yan on Keuka Lake and only 5 miles from Seneca Lake. We were able to visit many vineyards located along both lakes. Ports Cafe was suggested for dinner and it was a gem!!
by wendy from Burtonsville, MD
Great place to stay!Posted Jul 5, 2016 on Hotels
Cindy and Casey were fantastic hosts. We were treated to a musical welcome, courtesy of Casey. Lovely Blues and Jazz tunes. Cindy had fresh baked cookies, and a wealth of advice about the area. They were eager to please, and have a beautiful property. Breakfast was fantastic, and the house is wonderful. I only wish we had stayed longer.
by Katrina from Lancaster, PA
Great B&B in the middle of Finger Lakes region.Posted May 31, 2016 on Hotels
Great place to overnight in Penn Yan. Close to Keuka lake and the downtown area and a short drive to Seneca lake and Watkins Glen. Innkeepers are great and offer a wealth of information on the area and things to do, wineries and restaurants worth stopping at. Rooms are clean, some are on the small side, but we only sleep there and don't need a ton of room. Breakfasts are great. House has a large wrap around porch that you can sit on and enjoy the morning or evening and a large a common area downstairs. Would highly recommend.
by Dawn from Canal Fulton, Ohii
Almost perfect.Posted May 26, 2016 on Hotels
The b and b was meticulous and owners were delightful. Breakfast was tasty and filling. Obly one negative. Smaller, cozy room if the home better suited forsingle traveler. Not sure bed is a queen...may be a double. Iveeall stay was greatwith on spot recommendations for local dining and wining.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Maine
Best Finger Lakes LocationPosted Sep 26, 2015
Pros: Everything, but especially the cleanliness.
Cons: There is nothing that needs to be improved.
Location: The wine country of the Finger Lakes is the best. Dining of every type is available within a short walk or short drive.
We could not have been made to feel more at home than Cindy and Casey made us feel. From the minute you walk through the door til the end of our stay was excellent. Cindy and Casey know how to run a B&B the way it is meant to be done. Their attention to dietary needs was taken into consideration when planning our breakfast, which by the way was excellent. We stayed in the Theater Room, which was so inviting, and so comfortable. And let me tell you about the bed linens, so unbelievable soft we wanted to ask Cindy and Casey where they get them. They are so knowledgeable about the area and attractions, giving us detailed maps of where we wanted to go. We do plan on returning to the Finger Lakes and this is the only place we will consider staying at.