Ratings based on 1,524 Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.4 Room cleanliness
4.4 Service & staff
4.4 Room comfort
4.1 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Detroit
Beautiful hotel, nice pool, great breakfastPosted Nov 29, 2015
Pros: The breakfast room and the hotel rooms have a great view of the marina, and some views of the beach as well. The beach is right across the street.
Location: Near to the airport and not far from downtown.
We preferred staying here to the big Sheraton where a conference was going on. This place had great character, and their shuttle can take you to the Sheraton as well as the airport and other destinations.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from San Jose, Costa Rica
Great hotel on the BayPosted Nov 25, 2015
Pros: Convenience to downtown and the airport, on the water and the food.
I needed some place away from San Diego Convention Center to relax after a 3 day event. This was the perfect place. Great walking, big spacious room, good food and the staff was so attentive.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Austin, TX
Posted Nov 25, 2015
Stayed there 3 nights for business in San Diego. Room had nice view, good size, very clean, great happy hour deals on food and drink each day, walk across the street to the bay.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Scottsdale AZ
Why did I leave?Posted Nov 21, 2015
Pros: Everything was to my liking! Friendly staff and great restaurant with a bar facing the slips with all those beautiful yacht's. Huge room! Loved it.
Cons: Not one thing.
Location: Walking, biking , fishing , boating , beautiful view of the bay lights.
I only stayed at the Bay Club for one night and was going to go up the coast to Newport beach. I went deep sea fishing in the morning and was too tired to make the drive north so I stayed at the Dana on Mission Bay across from the docks. I opened the door and I was not impressed at all. I had to pay more and get so much less. I gave up a water view at the Bay Club for a noisy road view. I will go back to the bay club every visit. I found this hotel by mistake and was so impressed with it all. I was really upset that I didn't stay longer.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from palm springs, ca.
very nice hotelPosted Nov 18, 2015
Pros: Employees and the view
Location: great seafood restaurants and humphreys next door with outdoor concerts.
I have stayed there before and enjoy coming back. People are nice and view is great.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Charleston, SC
My opinionPosted Nov 17, 2015
Pros: My room was excellent and had a wonderful view as I had hoped.
Cons: Previously mentioned
Location: Great location and close to other restaurants and downtown was a 20 minute easy drive.
I enjoyed everything about this hotel with two exceptions. 1) the additional cost to park a car. I have never understood this. How else would someone come to the hotel except by taxi. 90% of people have a car so why not just price the rooms accordingly and not have an additional expense? 2) I drink only beer and only one kind of beer. They had my brand on Thursday and ran out at happy hour on Friday around 6:00 pm and didn't restock the entire rest of my stay so in order to have a relaxing day after work, I had to get in my vehicle and drive somewhere else. I was frustrated and furious. The last thing I wanted to do in the rain on Saturday afternoon is get back in my vehicle and search for a comfortable bar to relax in. I was not happy about it.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
Posted Nov 14, 2015
Wonderful hotel! Far exceeded my expectations! Friendly staff, nice sized room! Will definitely be back and sure to recommend!
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Irvine, Ca
Great view of the marina.Posted Nov 9, 2015
Nice, quiet, well deserved weekend. This location on Shelter Island is a great place to get away.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler
The Best Ever!Posted Nov 9, 2015
Pros: Location on Shelter Island; it overlooks the naval base and the pacific.
Cons: update the reception decors and front desk!
Location: it is located on the Shelter islands. it overlooks the Marine from one side and on the Pacific & naval base from the other side. Amazing location!
The hotel overlooks The Marina from one side and the pacific & the Naval base from the other side. I personally chose that my balcony overlooks the ocean side. It was amazing that I woke up in the morning and open the curtains looking at the ocean and smells it!!! Even, there is a little garden in front of the balcony. just wow! location of hotel is perfect where most of people are classy and nice. Staff are so amazing and great :) Thanks for the nice time! There is a nice little restaurant/bar overlooks the swimming pool and Jacuzzi for your relaxation!! Parking ain't free though, but WiFi is free and breakfast is included on the bill. There is a little computer and printer where you can print your itineraries totally for free for your convenience. I wish I visit back SD and I'll check in here again in the same room.
for Everyoneby A verified traveler from Williamsburg, VA
Nice hotel with awesome view of marina.Posted Nov 8, 2015
I enjoyed sitting on my balcony; the bar was fun too.