Photo gallery

Featured Image
TV, fireplace, video-game console, DVD player
TV, fireplace, video-game console, DVD player
Fridge, microwave, oven, stovetop
4 bedrooms, iron/ironing board, linens

Guest reviews

4.5 out of 5 Wonderful
31 reviews

Popular amenities

Air Conditioning
Pet Friendly
Outdoor Space


Explore the area

Popular LocationGreenport Carousel25 min drive
Popular LocationKontokosta Winery31 min drive
Popular Location67 Steps Beach33 min drive
AirportEast Hampton, NY (HTO)43 min drive

Choose dates to view prices

    About this area

    Shelter Island Heights

    Located in Shelter Island Heights, this vacation home is on the waterfront. Gardiner's Bay Country Club and Shelter Island Whale's Tail are worth checking out if an activity is on the agenda, while those wishing to experience the area's natural beauty can explore Menhadden Lane Beach and Sunset Beach. Sailing offers a great chance to get out on the surrounding water, or you can seek out an adventure with hiking/biking trails nearby. Our guests love the property's quiet location.

    Visit our Shelter Island Heights travel guide
    Popular Location

    What's nearby

    • Mashomack Preserve - 8 min drive
    • Greenport Carousel - 25 min drive
    • Kontokosta Winery - 31 min drive
    • Truman's Beach - 32 min drive
    • 67 Steps Beach - 33 min drive

    Getting around

    • Greenport Station - 25 min drive
    • East Hampton, NY (HTO) - 43 min drive


    • Marie Eiffel Market - 5 min drive
    • The Dory - 5 min drive
    • Sweet Tomato's - 5 min drive
    • Bella Vita - 5 min drive
    • Bella Vita Pizza - 5 min drive

    Guest reviews

    Overall score and ratings for Beach Front, Renovated Summer Home in Picturesque Island

    31 reviews
    5 - Excellent
    4 - Good
    3 - Okay
    2 - Mediocre
    1 - Poor
    4.0 out of 5 Good
      Haybeach House summer 2020

      The house was large enough for my group and clean. I have some concerns about renting again with this owner. The home itself needs attention. The outside decking is very weak and unsafe in areas and needs to be replaced immediately. The top step on the back of the house is breaking away. The gutters are clogged.And the house needs a good power wash. We couldn’t use the outside the picnic umbrella because it was broken. On the interior, The stairwell needs a railing. Finally there is mold in the lower half of the house. The smell is over powering and is deemed uninhabitable.

      5.0 out of 5 Excellent
        Can’t wait to go back!

        My family and I enjoyed a relaxing 4 days at Kate’s place. For all of us it was not only our first time booking a home but also visiting Shelter Island. Both experiences exceeded our expectations. The house was great, open with great light, and extremely comfortable for our group of 8. The house is wonderfully located just mins from everything the IGA market, the town center and most importantly the beach. Kate was super prompt in her communications and We can’t wait to make another visit to this wonderful island and home. Kate thank you for a wonderful time.

        4.0 out of 5 Good
          Peaceful and quiet location

          Plenty of space, quiet surroundings. Great location for walks. Easy access by car and by foot to various beaches. Kate is responsive and easy to reach.

          4.0 out of 5 Good
            Nice getaway house

            The house was a welcome break from the city. The location of the house to the beach is terrific. The house was in good condition, had enough space for us and was a good place to spend time.

            3.0 out of 5 Okay
              Better Upkeep

              The house is lovely and has the potential to be an amazing vacation home on this magical island. However, during our stay we encountered many small challenges that could have been easily taken care of if someone was properly looking after the house. For instance, one of the bedroom doors locked if you closed it and could not be opened unless someone opened it from the outside. We tried to get this fixed during our two week stay but no one took care of this issue. Also a lot of the rooms did not have working lightbulbs, and there were no light bulbs in the house for us to replenish the dead bulbs. And lastly, a lot of the kitchen supplies were either outdated or just broken and did not work. Despite these "household" issues, we had a lovely stay in Shelter Island and were very happy to get some time in the sea.