Find hotels in Shelter Island, NY from $63

Most hotels are fully refundable. Because flexibility matters.

Save 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide as a One Key member.

Search over 2.9 million properties and 550 airlines worldwide.

Filter by

Popular filters
Popular filters
Guest rating
Guest rating
Star rating
Payment type
Payment type
Property type
Property type
Neighborhood
Neighborhood
Popular locations
Popular locations
Meal plans available
Meal plans available
Amenities
Amenities
Accessibility
Accessibility
Traveler experience
Traveler experience

Compare 4,700 hotels, room rates, hotel reviews and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.

Where to stay in Shelter Island

Find the best Shelter Island areas and neighborhoods for the activities you enjoy most. Learn more about Shelter Island

More cheap stays in Shelter Island

Stay near popular Shelter Island attractions

Shelter Island Travel Info

Number of reviews
2,664
Accommodation
4,700 hotels
Highest price
$725
Lowest price
$63

Frequently asked questions

Where is the best place to stay in Shelter Island?

Located 18.4 mi (29.7 km) from the heart of Shelter Island, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is a top choice for your stay based on our traveler data. Other good choices for your trip to the area are Montauk Manor and Montauk Oceanside Suites. See all available top hotels, or vacation rentals in Shelter Island.

What's the top vacation rental that Shelter Island has to offer?

Beautiful 3 bedroom Residence in the Hamptons: You might want to consider this vacation rental near Shelter Island, which offers an outdoor pool, a barbecue grill, and air-conditioning to help you feel perfectly comfortable in your new surroundings. See all vacation rentals in Shelter Island.

If I need to cancel my hotel reservation in Shelter Island, will I receive a refund?

Yes, the majority of hotel room reservations are fully refundable as long as you cancel before the accommodation's cancellation deadline, which is often 24 or 48 hours before your scheduled arrival. If you booked a non-refundable reservation, you might be able to still cancel and get a refund within a 24-hour period of your booking. Filter your search by fully refundable to find flexible hotel deals in Shelter Island.

Where can I learn more about changing or cancelling my trip to Shelter Island?

For additional details about picking new dates or cancelling your trip to Shelter Island, click here.

Where is the best hotel to stay with easy access to Mashomack Preserve?

The Harborfront Inn is one of the top choices for your stay based on our traveler data, and this 3.5-star hotel offers free breakfast and a 24-hour fitness center. It's located 3.7 mi (6 km) from Mashomack Preserve.

What about the best place to stay near Havens House?

One of the top choices for your stay is The Harborfront Inn, located 3.1 mi (4.9 km) from Havens House, and this 3.5-star hotel offers free breakfast and a 24-hour fitness center.

What are some accommodations with pools in Shelter Island?

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa: Resort, 13-minute walk from The Hamptons Beaches. Features a seasonal outdoor pool, an indoor pool, and a private beach. Montauk Manor and Water's Edge Resort & Spa are a couple of other choices that feature an onsite pool. View all hotels with pools in Shelter Island.

What is the best spa hotel in Shelter Island?
What is the best accommodation for staying close to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)?

Holiday Inn Express Kennedy Airport is a popular hotel, featuring free breakfast and free WiFi. It's located a short 1.5 mi (2.5 km) from John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport. Other options near the airport are Fairfield Inn by Marriott JFK Airport and Radisson Hotel JFK Airport.

What's it like to stay in Shelter Island?

Visitors can enjoy all that Shelter Island has to offer including the parks, beaches, and museums. This city also attracts tourists with its scenic landscape. In Shelter Island, there are 97 hotels and other accommodations to choose from. Find out more about Shelter Island.

What should I see while I'm in Shelter Island?

Natural beauty is on display at Sunset Beach, Mashomack Preserve, and Crescent Beach. A couple of additional sights to add to your agenda are Shell Beach and Gardiner's Bay Country Club. Check out what more to see and do in Expedia's Shelter Island guide.

What's the weather like in Shelter Island?

The hottest months are usually August and July with an average temp of 70°F, while the coldest months are January and February with an average of 38°F. Average annual precipitation for Shelter Island is 57 inches.

Recent reviews of Shelter Island hotels
Expedia verified reviews