We stayed in a King bedroom in the brick building to the left of the main Inn building, and really enjoyed our stay! The room was super clean upon entry, and very spacious (as was the bathroom). The property and buildings have been around for a while, so they have that old Inn feel (slanted floors in places, a bit of an older building smell but not unclean or bothersome to us). The only thing we didn't love was the temperature control - there is no thermostat in the room and it got a bit warm at night. The bed was very comfortable, and the Inn provides plenty of linens/towels. Overall, we really liked the room.
The check-in is definitely not like a traditional Inn. It is done all virtually unless you go into the main building looking for help (where we did find Mary, who was able to get us into our room an hour early - much appreciated!). We did not mind this, but I can see how it might be a turn off to some.
We missed dinner in the Tavern, which looked delicious, but the Country Store right next door is great. We got some snacks/drinks for the room there, as well as breakfast one morning. They have a great selection of local food/drink items & gifts, as well as the usuals.