Ratings based on 125 Verified Reviews

They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
3.4 out of 5
84% of guests recommend
4.0 Room cleanliness
3.7 Service & staff
3.7 Room comfort
3.2 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
We double-checked.
4 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified traveler from l

Nice hotel in heart of town

Posted Feb 4, 2016
Great historic hotel close to great food and shopping
3 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified traveler from New York, NY

Amazing Staff

Posted Feb 1, 2016
Pros: Cool and quirky... Located in the heart of Christiansted. Breakfast included.
Cons: The taxi cab/ "tour guide driver" that this hotel suggests. DO NOT USE RUDYs Taxi. They will ripp you off. Rent a car, it's cheaper and more fun.
Location: On the boardwalk of harbor. Snorkling Diving .Bars Restaurants
Checking in was quick, easy and Front Desk was very welcoming. We booked a classic room which was located in the historic part of the hotel. Our room was located on the 3rd floor attic level of an old historic building . Very quirkie and cool. Definitely not your typical hotel and that's what makes it an experience. I would reccommend it for a great weekend getaway in the heart of Christiansted. The continental breakfast was very nice and again a special shout out to Ms. Onica who was more than a front desk agent, she was a concierge as well.
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified traveler from Northern California

Vintage hotel with Danish ambiance.

Posted Jan 28, 2016
Pros: Location, location, ambiance, and view of the harbor. The large reading areas on the deck or near the pool was superb.
Cons: If assigned to the third floor in the older section, it would be good to warn people about the narrow stairway & more breakfast fruit at would be good
Location: Great view of the Seaborne seaplanes taken off every few hours. There are at least five restaurants and ten bars within 600 feet.
Because my wife and I lived on St. Croix 30 years ago, we wanted to be in the heart of Christiansted activity, particularly a hotel with walk-ability to the boardwalk, shops and restaurants and of course the beautiful harbor view. We remembered the Club Comanche, now Hotel St. Croix, as a hot spot and hoped it was not damaged too badly by 1989 Hugo hit. We were delighted to find that the hotel was in good shape (not perfect as the old elevator is down for the count) but the wonderful feeling of being in a solidly built 200 year old wooden and stone building with all its history. One must accept the echoing noise of the late night bar revelers, which at about 5:00am will be replaced by the roosters crowing endlessly. So for light sleepers, ear plugs are recommended. But for us, the unique hotel was so much better then renting a condo up-island or a modern room in a hotel without character or history. So with the superb location and VERY friendly front desk staff and general help, it was the perfect spot for us. We plan to return to the hotel on our next visit and hopefully by then the famous Club Comanche Restaurant will be again open.
2 out of 5
by A verified traveler

Needs work on facilities and service

Posted Jan 17, 2016
Web pics are not accurate. First room was nothing less then a disaster (#22). They changed us to renovated section in the main house which was much better; clean & comfortable, but unfortunately not a lot worked; phone, safe, hot water lukewarm 2 out of 6 days and the other days none at all. Some staff very nice others really could care less and acted like it. We travel a lot and accept a lot of variances and situations when we travel and I was honestly disappointed.
5 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified traveler

Staff is very nice & acconmodating

Posted Dec 23, 2015
You are so close to all the shops,restaurants,can even go swimming at the hotel across for $5.round trip very nice
2 out of 5
Recommended
for Couples
by William

Posted Oct 28, 2015 on Hotels
hotel needs upgrade
3 out of 5
Recommended
for Couples
by Merrill from md

Posted Oct 28, 2015 on Hotels
The stay was nice. Just had to deal with a mouse, a few roaches and A LOT of MOSQUITOES
4 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified traveler

Old but charming

Posted Oct 22, 2015
Pros: Historical charm in building, but some area buildings look a bit beaten up. Nice, helpful staff, access to pool, walking distance to much in town.
Cons: The oldness stands out - creeky floors, stairs, but with character. Neighborhood away from beach less nice.
Location: Good cafes, bars, access to beaches, water sports, Buck Island. Go to Twin City Coffee, Yoga center, Cafe Fresco. Many places close early, though
This is not any kind of resort, but the whole town is full of quite old buildings, so it's like its surroundings. Wood floors, pretty clean overall, a good continental breakfast, very nice and friendly staff and right in the middle of shopping, coffee, cafes, tours with boats, snorkeling, great beaches and even a Yoga business next door. You can walk anywhere locally and only need transportation if you want to go to Sugar Beach, Salt Bay or east to somewhere like Green Cay and Point Udall. And there's a car rental right there, too. I would come back.
3 out of 5
Recommended
for Getaway With Friends
by A verified traveler

Vacation Getaway

Posted Oct 17, 2015 on Hotels
My overall stay was good. The hotel doesn't have an elevator so you have to climb stairs with your luggage. The hotel is located in the heart of town so it was a bit noisy. Lots of boosters crowing. Room needed blackout curtains because the sunlight made the room too bright in the morning. It was hard to sleep past 6:15 AM because of noise and the room being so bright. My cousin an I stayed at this hotel for a short visit to St. Croix. The staff was friendly and helpful.
4 out of 5
Recommended
for Everyone
by A verified traveler

Nice Historical Hotel

Posted Oct 12, 2015
Pros: large rooms decorated with a Virgin Island feel.
Cons: sound proofing....you can hear everyone else.
Location: Great location....nearby all of the stores and restaurants
The hotel was close to the boardwalk and more reasonable than the surrounding locations. the staff was very nice and informative. the rooms had a nice historical field and made us feel like we were a part of the Virgin Island history. The continental breakfast was enough to fill us up for till lunch and the Chicken Shack was a delicious treat for lunch and dinner.