Find hotels near Old Whaler's Church, Sag Harbor from $135

Discover the top-rated hotels near Old Whaler's Church that promise an unforgettable stay in Sag Harbor.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaLocated just 3.0 miles from Old Whaler's Church, this luxurious retreat boasts an exceptional review rating of 10, making it a great choice for travelers. Guests can indulge in a year-round spa experience while enjoying amenities such as an outdoor heated pool, hot tub, and a private chef service. With options for windsurfing, kayaking, and nearby shopping, this retreat offers a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!Just 4.2 miles from Old Whaler's Church, this estate-like home is rated 10 by travelers, ensuring a remarkable stay. The hotel features a heated pool and is surrounded by beautiful landscapes, perfect for those seeking outdoor activities like golfing and kayaking. With a fully equipped kitchen, patio, and nearby marina access, travelers will find everything they need for a comfortable getaway.Room 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaksThis charming waterfront room is only a 9-minute walk from Old Whaler's Church and has an outstanding review rating of 10. Guests can enjoy a queen bed and the convenience of complimentary bikes and kayaks for exploring the scenic surroundings. With air conditioning for comfort, this cozy stay offers a unique experience for travelers looking for nearby local attractions.

Explore the perfect accommodations that enhance your visit to Old Whaler's Church, offering top-rated stays just a short stroll away.Room 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaksRoom 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaks is a stunning retreat located just a 9-minute walk from Old Whaler's Church. Rated an impressive 10 by travelers, this hotel features air conditioning for comfort and a sofa bed for added convenience. Guests can enjoy the serene waterfront views and easy access to bikes and kayaks, perfect for exploring Sag Harbor's beautiful surroundings.sunset bikes and kayaks in the villageSunset bikes and kayaks in the village offers a charming stay just a 9-minute walk from Old Whaler's Church, with a perfect review rating of 10. With air conditioning to keep travelers comfortable, this hotel provides a delightful home base for those looking to enjoy the local scenery. The availability of bikes and kayaks enhances the experience, allowing travelers to explore the picturesque village at their leisure.Room3, best waterfront view +shared bath, bikes+kayaksRoom3, best waterfront view +shared bath, bikes+kayaks is a fantastic choice for travelers seeking nearby Old Whaler's Church, located just 9 minutes away on foot. With a top review rating of 10, this hotel features air conditioning for a pleasant stay. The shared bath is complemented by breathtaking waterfront views, and travelers can take advantage of the bikes and kayaks available for an adventurous day out in Sag Harbor.

Searching for family-friendly hotels near Old Whaler's Church can lead to delightful experiences for your stay in Sag Harbor.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaLuxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round Spa is an exceptional family-friendly option just 3.0 miles from Old Whaler's Church, with a stellar review rating of 10. Families will appreciate the highchair and toys for children, along with a spacious garden and game room. Guests can enjoy amenities such as a heated pool, outdoor patio, and access to windsurfing and kayaking, making it perfect for a memorable getaway.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay! is a top family retreat located just 4.2 miles from Old Whaler's Church, with an outstanding review rating of 10. This hotel features a secure yard, a game room with arcade games, and a kitchen equipped for family meals. Additional amenities include a heated pool, outdoor patio, and nearby paddleboating options, ensuring a fun-filled experience for travelers of all ages.Topping Rose HouseTopping Rose House, located 4.5 miles from Old Whaler's Church, is a luxurious 4.5-star hotel rated 9.2 by travelers. This family-friendly hotel offers amenities like cribs and babysitting services, making it easy for parents to relax. Guests can also enjoy an outdoor pool, spa services, and a beautiful terrace. The hotel is perfect for families seeking comfort and sophistication with plenty of nearby attractions.

Discover the best hotels near Old Whaler's Church that combine stunning views and top-rated amenities for a perfect getaway in Sag Harbor.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!With an exceptional review rating of 10, this 4-star hotel is located just 4.2 miles from Old Whaler's Church. Guests can enjoy breathtaking beach views from the patio and access to various water activities like paddleboating, kayaking, and windsurfing nearby. The estate features a private heated pool, a spacious garden, and a cozy fireplace for relaxation. Ideal for nature enthusiasts, it also offers hiking and biking opportunities right at your doorstep.

Discovering affordable hotels near Old Whaler's Church can enhance your visit with comfortable stays and convenient access to this charming landmark. Here are some top-rated options that cater to families and offer great amenities.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaJust 3.0 miles from Old Whaler's Church, the Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round Spa offers a serene escape with a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure. Rated by travelers with a remarkable score of 10, this hotel features a heated outdoor pool, a hot tub, and a fitness center nearby for those looking to stay active. Guests can also enjoy spacious living areas and a patio perfect for family gatherings.Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay!Located 4.2 miles from Old Whaler's Church, the Family Friendly, Estate Like Home, Heated Pool Seconds to Bay! is an ideal choice for families seeking comfort and fun. With a perfect review rating of 10, this spacious home offers a heated pool and easy access to nearby beaches. Families will appreciate the toys for children, alongside amenities such as a game room and a well-equipped kitchen, ensuring a delightful stay for all ages.Room 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaksSituated just a short 9-minute walk from Old Whaler's Church, Room 1 queen bed on waterfront + bikes and kayaks offers a cozy and convenient stay for travelers. With a perfect review rating of 10, this waterfront room includes air conditioning for comfort. Guests can also enjoy complimentary bikes and kayaks, perfect for exploring the scenic surroundings and making the most of their Sag Harbor experience.

If you're looking for top-rated hotels with pools near Old Whaler's Church, these exceptional options in Sag Harbor provide a perfect blend of comfort and relaxation.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaJust 3.0 miles from Old Whaler's Church, Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round Spa is a stunning getaway a perfect 10 review rating. This family-friendly hotel features a vast outdoor heated pool, ensuring a refreshing experience for travelers. Additional amenities include a hot tub, a fitness center, and a private chef service, catering to all your relaxation needs.Private Rustic Lodge on 3.5 acres - Ideal for relaxing and the HolidaysLocated 4.5 miles from Old Whaler's Church, the Private Rustic Lodge offers a tranquil escape with a remarkable 9.8 review rating. This lodge features a private outdoor pool, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploration. Guests can also enjoy amenities such as a cozy fireplace, air conditioning, and nearby access to paddleboating and winery tours.New and Modern Bridgehampton AccommodationsNew and Modern Bridgehampton Accommodations is situated just 3.2 miles from Old Whaler's Church and boasts an impressive 9.4 travelers' rating. This hotel offers a shared heated outdoor pool, making it an ideal spot for families and friends alike. With additional amenities like a hot tub, fitness facilities, and easy access to local beaches, travelers are sure to have a delightful stay.

For travelers seeking pet-friendly accommodations near Old Whaler's Church, these exceptional hotels offer the perfect blend of comfort and amenities for you and your furry friend.Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/Sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-Round SpaThis stunning hotel, rated a perfect 10 by travelers, is only 3.0 miles from Old Whaler's Church. It offers extensive pet-friendly amenities, allowing pets in rooms and providing a spacious environment for them to roam. Guests can indulge in a private heated pool, hot tub, and a fully equipped kitchen, all while enjoying nearby beach access and various outdoor activities.Private Rustic Lodge on 3.5 acres - Ideal for relaxing and the HolidaysLocated 4.5 miles from Old Whaler's Church, this Private Rustic Lodge boasts an impressive review rating of 9.8. It welcomes pets and offers a tranquil setting on 3.5 acres. Guests will appreciate the private in-room pool, outdoor patio, and kitchen facilities, making it ideal for a cozy getaway with pets while enjoying nearby hiking and beach activities.Bridgehampton InnBridgehampton Inn is a charming 3.5-star hotel located just 4.8 miles from Old Whaler's Church, featuring a stellar review rating of 9.4. This inn welcomes pets with various amenities including in-room pet allowances and daily housekeeping. Guests can enjoy a beautiful terrace, complimentary cribs, and a lush garden, making it a serene retreat for both pets and their owners.

To look for discounts on hotels near Old Whaler's Church, join One Key™—our free travel rewards program. One Key members always get our best prices and earn OneKeyCash™* on eligible bookings for every dollar spent. Another way to save is by bundling your hotel and flights together on Expedia.*Excludes taxes and fees. OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Expedia and other participating brands.