Katama Vacations from $757

No staff at site, instructions for check-in unclear and confusing, rooms are fine, but way too expensive for what you are paying, you are mostly paying for location of the hotel, not your room

The room was tastefully furnished and clean. The hotel balcony overlooked the harbor and got morning sun: I had my morning coffee there. Staff respected my wish to not be disturbed during my 4-day stay but were present when I needed them. Water was hot and abundant. Hotel wifi was glitch-less and fast enough for my needs. Ferries to the mainland were within easy walking distance from the hotel, even with luggage (and taxis are readily available if you prefer to ride). Also within walking distance is a supermarket, an art theatre and plenty of restaurants (but no bars because Tisbury is a dry town). Local transit buses pass in front of the hotel and connect to all Island points (including to bars in nearby Oak Bluffs). The hotel is comfortable, convenient and low cost (for the Island): what more do you need?

Beautifully remodeled. Quiet. It has a common area with kitchen and living room space. Several entrances. Plenty of parking. Easy check in.

Courteous staff. Tub fixtures need upgrading. Bed could have been firmer.

It was pretty quiet while we were there so the breakfast was grab and go and the restaurants were closed but everything else about the hotel and the area were great. We had a lovely room - the location is perfect and there was enough going on in the town. Shame about the rain Late November