Find hotels in Middle Cay from $166

"We enjoyed our stay at paradise found. The location was just around the corner from the Spanish wells swings near the park. The house was very spacious, clean and had most everything needed. April helped connect us with a taxi from the airport upon arrival to the docks. The golf cart provided was also great!"

"Clean room and the staff is incredible."

"House was great and has everything you need. The host was very responsive and made it easy to coordinate ahead of arrival and during the stay. Very close to the beach and places to eat. Highly recommend."

"Air conditioning excellent. Clean and well located. "

"Excellent vacation house for the family. Everybody had space, the property is well maintained, and the staff were wonderful. "

"Amazing property, spa, gym and is appropriate for families and couples. "

"immaculate property with friendly efficient staff. stayed in a newly renovated briland room which was beautiful. food was delicious (although the continental breakfast is a bit sparse). beach is incredible. so wide and soft like baby powder and you can walk forever on beach or in water which is shallow and clean. there is a little putting green, tennis and pickleball, gym with sauna and ice plunge. wish they had a spa. a wonderful place. "

"Wonderful"

"Review for Tingum Village, Harbour Island My wife and I had a smooth and pleasant check-in at Tingum Village. We were given a wonderful room with a comfortable king-size bed, and it set the tone for a fantastic stay. The staff were exceptional—helpful, friendly, and always willing to go the extra mile. This isn’t a 5-star hotel, but it delivered exactly what we were looking for: comfort, charm, and genuine hospitality. It felt like a true home away from home. Thank you to all the staff for the warm welcome and for making our stay memorable. Rory & Rehana Armstrong"