Positive: Great location! Close to water, fishing, pier, wineries, state parks, shops, lighthouses, etc.
Negatives: The house is in desperate need of repair/maintenance. The bathroom had so much mold in it, including on the ceiling. In the shower, the caulk and the decorative crevices in the soap/shampoo holders were filled in with mold. The carpet looked like the original and turned the bottoms of our socks black. It has the most sparsely stocked kitchen we have ever experienced in a VRBO, i.e. no pepper, bakeware, or condiments. Bring your own everything and do NOT count on the "grocery" store in Wilson. Stop in Lockport or Buffalo. Stovetop is disgusting. Only one stainless steel pan was usable, the rest were not, unless you like shards of the material in your food. Garbage disposal clogs routinely. Most of the glassware are coffee mugs. Cable TV subscription does not include any networks nor ESPN (It is football season!). There are 4 thermostats, and it is difficult to tell which one controls what. It would be miserable to stay here in the middle of summer as it was warm enough upstairs in October even with the portable air conditioner on. When it rains and the wind is from the East, expect water beside the kitchen "table" and below the window in the master bedroom loft. Couch/sectional uncomfortably seats only 2 with the added bonus of a soccer ball size stain on the carpet from who knows what. There's a toilet in the kitchen. Try Google-ing "toilet plume."
