The Best 4 Star Hotels in Fishers Island, NY from $212

A calm lake with several boats anchored in the distance, surrounded by grassy banks and a rocky shoreline.

Upfront pricing
Our total price for your stay includes taxes and fees
Treat yourself
Save 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide with Member Prices
Learn about One Key
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check availability on Fishers Island 4 Star Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Our top choices for Fishers Island 4-star hotels

Room, 1 King Bed, Corner | Pillowtop beds, in-room safe, laptop workspace, iron/ironing board

1. Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa

Groton

Craig

$184 nightly

$212 total

Oct 12 - Oct 13

Total with taxes and fees

Ocean View One Bedroom Suite | Premium bedding, in-room safe, iron/ironing board, rollaway beds (free)

2. Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Montauk

John

$512 nightly

$585 total

Oct 12 - Oct 13

Total with taxes and fees

2 restaurants; breakfast, lunch, and dinner served

Private beach, beach towels, kayaking, fishing

3. Montauk Yacht Club

Montauk

Charalampos

$320 nightly

$366 total

Oct 15 - Oct 16

Total with taxes and fees

2 indoor pools, open 6 AM to 10 PM, cabanas (surcharge), pool umbrellas

4. Mohegan Sun

Montville

Mary

$217 nightly

$250 total

Oct 1 - Oct 2

Total with taxes and fees

Seasonal outdoor pool, pool umbrellas, sun loungers

Beachfront King | Blackout drapes, iron/ironing board (on request), WiFi (free)

5. Marram

Montauk

NATAVAN

$321 nightly

$367 total

Oct 12 - Oct 13

Total with taxes and fees

Ocean View 2 Queens | Premium bedding, down comforters, pillowtop beds, WiFi (free)

6. Offshore Montauk

Montauk

Jaime

$270 nightly

$309 total

Sep 29 - Sep 30

Total with taxes and fees

Suite, Multiple Beds | Living area | 32-inch flat-screen TV with cable channels, TV, table tennis

Suite, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed | Living area | 32-inch flat-screen TV with cable channels, TV, table tennis

Suite, Multiple Beds | Egyptian cotton sheets, premium bedding, down comforters, pillowtop beds

7. Hotel Corduroy

Culloden Shores

Dhurata

$221 nightly

$252 total

Oct 14 - Oct 15

Total with taxes and fees

On the beach, sun loungers, beach towels

8. Hero Beach Club

Montauk

Kwok Keet

$287 nightly

$328 total

Sep 28 - Sep 29

Total with taxes and fees

One Bedroom Residence King with Ocean View | Living area | 55-inch Smart TV with digital channels, Netflix, Hulu

One Bedroom Residence King with Ocean View | Beach/ocean view

9. Offshore Spa & Residences

Downtown Montauk

"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ We had such a wonderful stay at Offshore Montauk! The hotel is beautifully designed, incredibly clean, and the location couldn’t be better—just steps from the beach and an easy walk to Montauk’s restaurants and shops. The rooms are stylish, comfortable, and so peaceful. We especially loved the pool, sauna, and cold plunge—they were the perfect way to relax and recharge after a day at the beach. Most importantly, the staff was genuinely welcoming and made us feel at home from the moment we...

Iryna

$639 nightly

$730 total

Oct 14 - Oct 15

Total with taxes and fees

Queen Room with Garden View and Shared Bath | Terrace/patio

Queen Room with Jetted Tub and Fireplace (Not Pet Friendly) | Fireplace

10. Abbey's Lantern Hill Inn

Ledyard

claudio

$219 nightly

$252 total

Sep 17 - Sep 18

Total with taxes and fees

11. East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

Clearwater Beach

IVAN

$685 nightly

$782 total

Sep 28 - Sep 29

Total with taxes and fees

Blue Grotto | Iron/ironing board, WiFi (free), individually decorated

Rosa | Iron/ironing board, WiFi (free), individually decorated

12. The Villa Bed & Breakfast

Westerly

Sam

Miss Anna James Room | Iron/ironing board, WiFi (free), individually decorated

Katharine Hepburn Room | Iron/ironing board, WiFi (free), individually decorated

13. James Pharmacy Bed & Breakfast

Old Saybrook Center

Diane

Premium bedding, pillowtop beds, minibar, in-room safe

14. DELAMAR MYSTIC

Rossie Velvet Mill Historic District

lisa

15. New London Hideaway Near Beaches & Local Spots!

New London

"Great vacay apartment and backyard, slept 5 comfortably, could do 6-8 with kids. Unit was perfectly equipped for our 4 day stay's every need - many fluffy towels, shower gel & shampoo, streaming TV, board games, comfy bedding, every kind of kitchen item, ice and free coffee supplies. Light and sunny apt close to beach, eateries, shops, downtain, train/ferry, Fort Trumbull & Colleges/CGA. The rolling beach cart with beach chairs and towels was perfect for a visit to Ocean Beach or Harkness SP...

Lisa

16. Mystic Refuge w/ Patio < 1 Mi to Downtown!

Mystic

"Perfect stay for our trip with my teenage kids to Mystic. The place was very clean, and stocked with coffee and snacks. I read other reviews about the tricky parking. I didn't even try to get my minivan in the narrow driveway, but the dental office parking lot is just across the side street so it was easy to bring things back and forth and much less stress. There was street noise but the AC drowned it out for the most part. We did some driving into town and also some walking. It was close to...

Kaitlin

Standard Room, 1 Full Canopy Bed with Fireplace | WiFi (free), individually decorated, individually furnished

17. Whitehall Mansion Inn

Mystic

Michelle

House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | Exterior

House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | Beach | On the beach

House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | 4 bedrooms

House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | Living room

18. Amagansett Beachfront Beauty

Napeague

19. Villa Lilith

Clearwater Beach

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Learn more about Fishers Island

This exclusive island retreat offers pristine beaches and the historic Henry L. Ferguson Museum showcasing local maritime heritage. Rent bicycles to explore the quiet roads or join a guided fishing charter to catch striped bass in the surrounding waters.

See all hotels in Fishers Island

A lighthouse on a rocky outcrop surrounded by water.

Top Fishers Island Hotel Reviews

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

10/10 Excellent

"Absolutely gorgeous stay!"

Find out more about Fishers Island

Fishers Island Four Star Hotel Information

When you need to book a room with luxurious amazing amenities and the best rates, the 4 star hotels in Fishers Island, New York are incredible options. Known for their extra perks, first-rate service, and fantastic locations, each of the Fishers Island 4 star hotels offers the ultimate experience for globe-trotting travelers. Relax in your expertly designed room. Kick back with around-the-clock room service.

Get a good night’s sleep with the ultra-plush bedding, and freshen up in the morning with designer-inspired body products. It’s all available when you stay at one of the top book a four star hotels in Fishers Island. What’s more, thanks to Expedia you might even score a cheap great deal on a 4 star hotel in Fishers Island, New York, areas near the hottest attractions, so you can plan a sightseeing adventure and take advantage of unbeatable discounts in one fell swoop.

Whether you’re putting together a serene getaway or want to revel in the most vibrant entertainment district, 4 star Fishers Island hotels offer everything your heart desires.

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to stay in a 4-star hotel in Fishers Island?

Expedia can help you quickly find the perfect 4-star hotel for your vacation in Fishers Island. Use our filter tool to fine-tune your search by things like price, conveniences and hotel star rating and get access to fabulous deals in a couple of clicks.

Search for the lowest price from $212

What's the difference between 5-star and 4-star hotels in Fishers Island?

Give yourself the luxury treatment during your Fishers Island getaway by choosing a 4-star hotel. As well as featuring upscale accommodations, these properties are usually filled with amenities such as bathrobes, large beds and more. A 5-star hotel will go the extra mile to make your stay an even more indulgent and memorable one. 24-hour concierge assistance, luxurious spas and world-class dining are a few of the superior services and conveniences you'll likely be able to enjoy.

Does Fishers Island have any 4-star all-inclusive resorts?

Enjoy a worry-free vacation experience where everything is included in the one rate by using our "All inclusive" filter. Budgeting is a piece of cake when your meals, accommodations and activities are already taken care of. After more options? Check out the incredible deals on Expedia's standard 4-star options in and around Fishers Island too.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Things to do in Montauk

Find 4 Star Hotels in Fishers Island, NY from $212

Upfront pricing

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check availability on Fishers Island 4 Star Hotels

Our top choices for Fishers Island 4-star hotels

1. Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa

2. Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

3. Montauk Yacht Club

4. Mohegan Sun

5. Marram

6. Offshore Montauk

7. Hotel Corduroy

8. Hero Beach Club

9. Offshore Spa & Residences

10. Abbey's Lantern Hill Inn

11. East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

12. The Villa Bed & Breakfast

13. James Pharmacy Bed & Breakfast

14. DELAMAR MYSTIC

15. New London Hideaway Near Beaches & Local Spots!

16. Mystic Refuge w/ Patio < 1 Mi to Downtown!

17. Whitehall Mansion Inn

18. Amagansett Beachfront Beauty

19. Villa Lilith

Learn more about Fishers Island

Top Fishers Island Hotel Reviews

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Find out more about Fishers Island

Fishers Island Four Star Hotel Information

Frequently asked questions

Explore a world of travel with Expedia