1. Buttermilk Falls Inn
- Location: Milton
- Guest rating: 8/10 (Very good, 75 reviews)
- Price: $494 nightly, $553 total, Nov 15 - Nov 16, Total with taxes and fees, for Our top choices for New Hamburg inns
- Review: Beautiful location and charming inn. Comfy bed. Could have been cleaner in the bathroom. This place could be amazing if it was maintained. Views of the Hudson River were covered by the messy gardens and trees. No restaurant., by Kristen