Extended Stay America - Meadowlands - East Rutherford Reviews

It was an easy check in. The room could have been cleaner

The hotel itself is pleasing. The receptionist was pleasing. The morning shuttle driver was pleasing. The evening shuttle driver never showed up one night, even though I called ahead and would have arrived before the last shuttle was supposed to be available - 9pm. Called at 8:35 from Penn Station, telling the hotel I needed a 9pm shuttle, was told "OK". Arrived at the shuttle pick up location at 8:55pm, no shuttle. Waited until 9:20pm before calling the hotel to ask if the shuttle was ever going to show up, was told they would call the driver again. At 9:40pm I gave up and took a taxi to the hotel. It ended up costing me $30 more that night because I needed to pay for a taxi from the train station. I stayed here to SAVE money people!!

This hotel was a great stay. The staff was friendly but it took some time before someone got to the front desk. The room was clean and the bed was comfortable.

Wow! What a great spacious room for a weekend stay. The full kitchen was a nice addition for saving money on food. I loved that the hotel was 5 minutes from the sports' complex. I enjoyed my stay with a good night's sleep. I was thoroughly satisfied.

Great hotel and rates. The staff was great and the place was very clean.

Very clean hotel. Staff was polite and location is close to stadium

If you don't mind DIY,this will be a good choice in comparison with the Hilton, the other side of the fence competitor which will charge 50% more. However, if it is the sale pitch, the hotel should provide more local info to help resident to find living necessities, a directory so to speak will be better than that from online search. Also a no smoking with 30 feet of the building will help. On May 22, my sleep was interrupted twice due to false alarms. I was told that someone smoking close to the entrance and set off the alarm. That is annoying.

I stayed at this hotel for 4 nights. Proximity to Manhattan is great. Also safe clean area and walmart and other shopping is near by. I wouldn't call this place a hotel. its more of an apartment building. Whenever i called front desk, they would never pick up. i got forwarded to a call answering service and they left message for front desk but never received a call back. Its not a 'fully-equipped' kitchen like they advertise it to be. There were only 2 cups, 2 forks, 2 spoons, 1 pan, 1 pot and 2 plates and bowls. No dishwasher. no dish soap or other utensils, or more plates. Room was not clean, there was dust all over. They still had their cleaning sprays and window screen shield, so they were probably rushed and didn't do a good job. Shuttle service to Seacaucus junction was limited during the day(only during rush hours) and on sunday the latest coming back was at 3pm which is stupid if you are in Manhattan late.

We arrived very late and had to call for better directions. Staff was very nice and very helpful.

Probably not worth the price. The free breakfast is a joke.