Search Brewster Cottages

"The property is a wonderful place to stay. The view is amazing from the wrap around porch. This is the 3rd time we have stayed there. Not far from Berlin, Sugar Creek, Mt. Hope, Charm or Walnut Creek. My sister and adult daughter love to get away there for a girls retreat. Eli is a wonderful host. It is very clean and comfortable and has a hot tub! The goats are a bonus."

"This charming farmhouse had everything we needed!! The atmosphere was perfect. The neighborhood was beautiful and quiet. We were lucky enough to be able to catch a glimpse of the northern lights our first night. We loved being able to watch all the birds go to the feeder next to the window in the kitchen, it made for a perfect morning. Cant wait to book this house again! Definitely a new favorite!!"

"Host was so nice! Adorable cottage and very clean. Will definitely be back for another stay."

"The cottage was so quaint and comfortable, it was difficult to leave to visit the area. Very well stocked with so many extras, better in life than the pictures. Enjoyed every moment and would definitely stay again, hopefully for more than three nights"

"This house is in the middle of Amish country. It's a short distance from the Amish country theater, Walnut Creek farm, lots of shopping in the area and lots of great Amish restaurants. This is a nice comfortable house."

"Beautiful, clean, and comfortable home in the PERFECT area. The country vibe provided an excellent site to relax while being close to all the actithe area has to offer. Despite the closeness to area fun, the rural location was the best part by far."

"The property was very nice. It was very clean and inviting."

"I can’t say that we’ve ever enjoyed a weekend getaway as much as this one. Staying on an active horse ranch submerged us into a whole different world. We learned so much about the horses and looked forward to going and seeing the horses throughout our stay. We will definitely be back!!"

"We took our family to the NFL Hall of Fame and had a fantastic experience. We loved relaxing in the countryside and enjoy the peaceful location. This is a beautiful location and id love to stay here again."

"Very quaint and loved the quiet and enjoying mornings sitting watching the pond."

"This was our 2nd time staying at this location, it is very convenient and comfortable and set in a perfect location for all the shops in town. Host was great on response and easy to work with. Look forward to our return in the near future. Thanks Jeff"

"The cabin was nice, in a quiet location and close to many shops, food and entertainment The only issue we experienced was other renters who let their dogs run loose and did not control them. This is not an issue with the rental but maybe a leash rule should be enforced since the outside grassy area is shared with all renters. The place is lovely and we enjoyed the surroundings and community. Thank you!"

"The cottage was absolutely stunning! Perfect location, easy check in! Will definitely return! The pool table was an added bonus! The place was perfect!"

"Would recommend!!!!"

"Great attention was given to details of cleanliness and comfort. A very welcoming home...cinnamon rolls, coffee, robes, even live plants. Convenient location in a quiet neighborhood."

"Our stay was very pleasant with all of the amenities of home! Would definitely stay there again!"

"This was a nicely furnished house and we had a great stay!"

"Very relaxing and quiet place. Very cozy and comfortable. Nothing but a positive experience."

"It is a beautiful cabin and very convient to all the shopping & restaurants. "

"It was one of the cleanest places we've been in a long time. I was suprised how much space was in the rooms, which made it more comfortable. We had three people in our room and didn't feel crowded, even though we set up a camping cot so we didn't have to share beds. The staff were also friendly and accepting to us and other people we saw in challenging situations. The shower ws big enough to turn around comfortably! (I have 22" shoulders and have often had trouble turning around in hotel...

"This is one of the most exceptional properties that we have ever stayed at. (It was a birthday gift from my wife). The online pictures do not do it justice. Everything from the room to the kitchen and the wrap around porches were clean and well maintained. We had a stunning view from the west facing porch. I can almost guarantee you that we'll be back."