Find hotels in Buffalo, IN from $58

Search over 1 million properties and 550 airlines worldwide.

Members save 10% more on select hotels, cars, activities and vacation rentals. Sign up.

Most hotels are fully refundable. Because flexibility matters.

Filter by

“Indiana Beach Rentals” on Shafer Lake, <br>Monticello, Indiana. Boat rental avail<br>
4.5/5 Wonderful! (15 reviews)
Great patio and deck
"We really enjoyed our stay here. The owner was very accessible if anything was needed. Great location if you enjoy being on the water."

Reviewed on Sep 12, 2021

Get rates
“Indiana Beach Rentals” on Shafer Lake, <br>Monticello, Indiana. Boat rental avail<br>
Rustic Luxury Estate On Lake Freeman
15.82 mi from city center
5/5 Exceptional! (70 reviews)
Luxury Home in Beautiful Setting
"Our family absolutely loved our stay at this home! The owners were so accomadating and really made us feel comfortable providing everything you would need for a relaxing family vacation. Everything was so clean and roomy! The rooms were beautiful and comfortable. The setting is beautiful and right ..."

Reviewed on Oct 13, 2021

Get rates
Rustic Luxury Estate On Lake Freeman
Specious 5 bdr Lake Shafer house with breathtaking view
7.31 mi from city center
4.8/5 Exceptional! (42 reviews)
Great Labor Day Stay!
"This house was perfect for our large group of friends for Labor Day weekend! The location was amazing, the house was clean, and just as described. I would definitely stay here again!"

Reviewed on Sep 21, 2021

Get rates
Specious 5 bdr Lake Shafer house with breathtaking view
You could be seeing lower prices

You could be seeing lower prices

With member prices, you could save 10% or more right now on thousands of properties.
Picturesque Getaway Tippecanoe River
19.58 mi from city center
4.9/5 Exceptional! (34 reviews)
Incredible place to get away
"My family rented the property for a week. We wanted to get away from the city, have a beautiful view of nature and be able to swim without worrying about covid. This place was wonderful. Great views all around! Patrick was a great host and offered great suggestions about tubing in the area. Thank ..."

Reviewed on Sep 9, 2021

Get rates
Picturesque Getaway Tippecanoe River
Summer Haven Resort
2.5 out of 5
4983 E. Indiana Beach Rd., Monticello, IN
6.91 mi from city center
3/5 (10 reviews)
Will be back.
"Staff was very nice and helpfull. I would and will stay again. Will admit a little upgrading is needed, but the new owner has taken over and plans to."

Reviewed on Aug 30, 2016

Get rates
Summer Haven Resort
Pine View Resort
2.5 out of 5
1969 N West Shafer Dr, Monticello, IN
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
The price is $70 per night from Oct 17 to Oct 17
7.68 mi from city center
3.3/5 (208 reviews)
"Clean place,had fridge,great price"

Reviewed on Oct 11, 2021

Pine View Resort
Nice 3 Bedroom House with beautiful view of Lake Freeman
4.7/5 Exceptional! (3 reviews)
Getaway at Monticello
"The property was wonderful. Just as described. Wanted to thank the owners for allowing us to feel welcomed. Definitely considered staying longer but didn’t know if we could book more time. Overall well worth the trip."

Reviewed on Sep 29, 2021

Get rates
Nice 3 Bedroom House with beautiful view of Lake Freeman
Lake front on Lake Freeman - a peaceful retreat!
14.21 mi from city center
5/5 Exceptional! (1 review)
Beautiful place
"It was perfect in every way. Just as described"

Reviewed on Aug 20, 2021

Get rates
Lake front on Lake Freeman - a peaceful retreat!
Serene Waterfront Monticello House w/ Fire Pit!
3.94 mi from city center
4.9/5 Exceptional! (52 reviews)
Relaxing getaway
"A lovely home, plenty of room for our family. Lovely outdoor space."

Reviewed on Sep 6, 2021

Get rates
Serene Waterfront Monticello House w/ Fire Pit!
'Cozy Cottage' w/Dock & Patio by Indiana Beach
3.97 mi from city center
5/5 Exceptional! (11 reviews)
Great place to stay
"2.of my friends and I stayed here earlier this year and the owners, husband and wife I believe, were very friendly, the house was very clean and cozy, and there was a great view of the lake. The only issue, which we spoke with the owners about, was the lack of access to the lake directly from the ..."

Reviewed on Dec 9, 2019

Get rates
'Cozy Cottage' w/Dock & Patio by Indiana Beach
Year round Lake home w/wonderful frontage, nice yard w/ fire pit, home theatre
4.8/5 Exceptional! (108 reviews)
The place was clean and had everything we needed
"The kids had a blast! We will definitely stay again"

Reviewed on Sep 30, 2021

Get rates
Year round Lake home w/wonderful frontage, nice yard w/ fire pit, home theatre
Pirate's Cove Resort
3 out of 5
4770 East Harbor Court, Monticello, IN
7.2 mi from city center
3.9/5 Good! (32 reviews)
"It is run down, like it needs a facelift. Also, could definitely clean up the grounds, lots of litter, weeds, please sweep that would help. Thought the bed was very comfortable though!"

Reviewed on Jun 13, 2021

Get rates
Pirate's Cove Resort
Andrew's Lakeside Resort
2 out of 5
4925 East Indiana Beach Road, Monticello, IN
The price is $119 per night from Oct 17 to Oct 17
6.9 mi from city center
3.1/5 (49 reviews)
"We came back every year, we love the place"

Reviewed on Jul 24, 2021

Andrew's Lakeside Resort
Indian Head Motel
2 out of 5
417 North US Highway 35, Winamac, IN
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
The price is $65 per night from Oct 16 to Oct 16
13.84 mi from city center
2.9/5 (24 reviews)
Good
"The motel is not bad for the price just a bit run down however Hotels.com has the address wrong and sends you to the middle of nowhere."

Reviewed on Mar 17, 2021

Indian Head Motel
Monticello Inn
2 out of 5
1273 W Broadway St, Monticello, IN
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
The price is $58 per night from Oct 17 to Oct 17
10.15 mi from city center
4/5 Very Good! (125 reviews)
"We had a group with 3 rooms from 3 different reservations. He went out of his way to group our rooms together. Very nice staff. Rooms were clean."

Reviewed on Oct 11, 2021

Monticello Inn
Lakeside Cottage w/ Spacious Multi-level Deck and Outdoor Living Space
Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites
2.5 out of 5
304 S 6th Street, Monticello, IN
Fully refundableReserve now, pay when you stay
The price is $130 per night from Nov 1 to Nov 1
10.28 mi from city center
4.2/5 Very Good! (331 reviews)
"Very nice property"

Reviewed on Oct 10, 2021

Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites
Lake Life Cabin on Lake Freeman
11.92 mi from city center
4.9/5 Exceptional! (15 reviews)
Great place!
"Very nice cabin, convenient to many attractions! Mary and Jim Skinner"

Reviewed on Aug 24, 2021

Get rates
Lake Life Cabin on Lake Freeman
Indiana Beach Waterfront property
The price is $99 per night from Oct 21 to Oct 21
0.51 mi from city center
4.1/5 Very Good! (26 reviews)
Simply perfect
"The biggest problem I had was a fish stole my fishing rod. . The Stay we had was fabulous . Perfect. Beautiful setting and dwelling. I'll definitely be back."

Reviewed on Sep 15, 2021

Indiana Beach Waterfront property
Pure Relaxation on the Tippecanoe River. #RiverLife
18.29 mi from city center
5/5 Exceptional! (24 reviews)
Fall break 2021
"We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the River House. The home was immaculate, and the owners provided so many extras that we didn't expect. Their attention to detail is a breat of fresh air. The only thing I would have changed is, I wished we could have stayed longer! Already trying to plan out next ..."

Reviewed on Oct 13, 2021

Get rates
Pure Relaxation on the Tippecanoe River. #RiverLife
Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available properties in Buffalo
View all properties
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Frequently asked questions

Recent reviews of Buffalo hotels