This property really deserves to be evaluated in its own category. It’s a 120-year-old establishment that has preserved its historic charm beautifully. The space was spotless, the staff were friendly, parking was easy, and the pillows were exceptionally comfortable (this is important! IYKYK)
That said, it’s important to know what comes with staying in a building of this age: the walls are thin, the hallways are narrow, the bathroom light/exhaust fan is loud, and the windows are original single-pane New England style. For me, those details were part of the character, not drawbacks.
I chose this location for its aesthetic appeal, and it absolutely delivered. The pink subway tile in the bathroom, opening the window on a spring day to overlook the city, and walking through the lobby with its brass postal box and decorative wrought iron railings all felt like stepping back into a more elegant era. Even the vintage elevator—with its button panel and rhythmic sounds as it moved between floors—encouraged you to slow down and take it all in.
I was in Buffalo for a show, and staying at the Lenox added something special to the experience. If you appreciate historic, non-chain accommodations, this is a place worth supporting.
I will absolutely stay again!
Reviewed on Apr 24, 2026
