Search Forestville Cottages

"We had a wonderful visit at this tiny house on the lake. Beautiful views. The house itself was open and spacious. Ended up we had a few tag alongs and it easily accommodated 6 adults. We will be back again! PS: You can fish from the beach."

"The property was beautiful and very warming! The property manager was extremely polite and helpful with any questions or issues. Overall my kids couldnt have had a better time being at the property and loved sitting on the inlet watching the ducks, beavers and geese every evening! Definitely recommend staying here if your traveling near Mayville."

"A very pleasant and quiet property on the lake. "

"Had three beds but sheets only for 2. Only one was made up. The location, however, is convenient and the price, reasonable."

"Excellent property, location, and host. Rachel was very friendly and responsive. Thank you!"

"We were pleased with the unit and the location. The only drawback was the gazebo had rusted scaffolding stored around it that took away any thoughts of enjoying it in the evening. That’s why we only gave the online listing three stars instead of five."

"Had a nice time. Very quiet. The arrangement of the bathroom and bedrooms is very bizarre. I do not recommend bringing kids if you want privacy with your partner. No door on main bedroom and bathroom is inside the main bedroom. Accordion door for secondary bedroom."

"Stayed here for the eclipse but got much more out of it. It was a nice quiet stay right on the lake which made for and enjoyable long weekend. Havinging th abilty to walk out, sit around a fire on a lake and fish was quite enjoyable. The tiny home was perfect for our needs and look forward to staying here again in the future. It was pet friendy yet lacked any animal hair which was a big concern as we had more than 1 person alerigic to dogs but had to bering out non shedding dog with us. Overall...

"We thoroughly enjoyed our stay here for a mini-adventure planned around the Solar Eclipse! The hosts were incredibly thoughtful and set out some much appreciated goodies for our arrival. House was the perfect amount of space for us, and all the furniture was comfortable (beds, couch, dining table). Loved having the washer and dryer and definitely used it. The beach is a quick leisurely walk and we found many neat stones and even some souvenir driftwood (score!). Also the drive to Buffalo was...

"Such a charming lake cottage located in a very quiet peaceful area. We really enjoyed the beautiful view of the bay with the assortment of water birds and even bald eagles gliding over the water. The fishermen had lots of fun catching nice bass right from the dock. We had both sunshine and cool rain and really appreciated the screened porch area. The cottage is decorated with a true relaxing lake vibe and enough room for everyone to gather together. Karen was very helpful with any questions we...

"We had a great stay! The house is nicely updated and comfortable. We didn’t plan to do a lot on this trip and stayed in the whole time. The house provided everything we needed for our stay. We would stay here again!"

"We loved being able to sit out back and look at the lake. Lots of beds was nice but no screens upstairs to be able to open windows. With no A/C it got hot. There were towels in the washer. Didn’t know what to do with them so we washed, dried and folded them. Would’ve like to have known about the hard water before getting there. There are a lot of spiders and bugs because of the lake. Windows were covered in spiderwebs."

"For the third time, our group of college friends stayed at Carley Two this summer, and just like the times before it was a treat. The property is clean and well maintained, the back porch with firepit and hot tub are spectacular, and the Ellicottville area has so much to do and see. We'll definitely be back."

"The property was beautiful. We had all the necessities. Proximity to the lake is fantastic. very relaxing. We will definitely rent again!"

"The house is exactly as advertised. The house is very clean, nicely furnished and comfortable. The kitchen is well apppointed with everything you need. The beds are comfortable. Very nice amenties throughout. Neighborhood was quiet (although this was April and not peak lake season). The neighbors are great. Large yard. A bit soggy duet to rain and mud management was a constant. Jason was awesome - excellent communications and very prompt on replies. If we get back to Lakewood, we would stay...

"Nice quiet getaway. Very nice updated place in a great location. Had everything we needed for a quiet night in and in a great location to visit the local wineries. Would definitely recommend and stay again."

"We had a wonderful stay. It's obvious that the house is designed thoughtfully. There are plenty of rentals that are obviously designed for photos and marketing, but the small touches really set this rental apart. The view is incredible, it's close to a local grocery, and you walk out onto a nice trail. We met the owners and they couldn't be more gracious hosts. Highly recommend."

"The house and property are very attractive and well cared for. We appreciated how clean and well stocked with essentials it was. It was a very convenient location for us to visit with family and enjoy the great water views. Whether indoors or out, we loved watching the activity on the water."

"Will definitely come back to this cottage it checked all the boxes"