1. Circa 1785

- Location: Historic District
- Guest rating: 9.4/10 (Exceptional, 194 reviews)
- Price: $195 nightly, $215 total, Nov 16 - Nov 17, Total with taxes and fees, for Our top choices for Sheldon guest houses
- Review: The bed was extremely comfortable. I enjoyed the large soaking tub. Conveniently located. Property has on-site free parking., by Ashley
