Mumford Vacations from $337

Very comfortable bed. Very clean. Friendly staff. Need more electrical outlets and we missed getting the trademark chocolate chip cookies

The bed was was too hard and uncomfortable.

The staff was really nice and helpful. The room was not completely clean upon arrival.

The Strathallan is long overdue for a renovation. The hallways are dingy and you can smell the years. The “living room” furniture is akin to the sofas and chairs one might find at the curb on garbage night. The bathroom sinks are higher than “comfort height” and the counter is too deep to make washing, brushing or shaving comfortable. This might be okay for someone 6’ 5” with very long arms, but not for anyone near average height. The HVAC system is as loud as it is old and the terraces are eroding. The lobby, however, is bright and welcoming, as is the staff. The lobby bar is terrific. I can only hope that the transition from DoubleTree by Hilton to Tapestry by Hilton is done swiftly. For now, the rates for rooms here are outrageous considering the condition of the rooms.

Our room and the entire building had so much character. The building access and security was easy and the room amenities were wonderful. The heating/ cooling was way too noisy though and the air velocity was so high that the warm air felt cool by the time it reached us.