This house worked well for us and we would return. We really enjoyed the beach club, the neighborhood was quiet, the rock slide and waterfall hike were great fun, and the house was comfortable for light cooking and family hangs. Our toddler had the biggest smile when he saw the toddler puzzles.
Taking the trash out was inconvenient, a 15 minute trip, and carpet had some light staining, but nothing that would stop us from returning. I give a 4.5 rating but rounding up!