We had a lovely time at the Broadway Exchange. It was like taking a step back in time, but with all the modern amenities. Really nicely updated - great tile, kitchen, furniture all top notch!
Bloedows bakery (walking distance) has amazing donuts and Kwik Trip is also walkable if you need anything.
Only issue we had was that the weekend was REALLY hot (90+ during the day) and the AC doesn't really get upstairs with the old duct work. We slept with the windows open, but it was pretty warm.
Loved everything else about the house & the hosts though...great stay.