Search Cortland Cottages

"We had a very nice stay at the Sandpiper Cottage. The host was very easy to communicate with and very sweet, and makes a delightful breakfast! Cute cottage, beautiful lake community and a fun atmosphere at Castaway Craigs! We enjoyed kayaking around the lake. Cant wait for our return."

"All was good. No complaints 😊"

"Our 2 families with 5 teenagers loved this cozy cottage! It was the perfect central location as we spent a long weekend hiking and disc golfing around Ohio. The back yard and patio would have been perfect if it were a little warmer! Just what we needed!"

"Nice central location and well kept clean property."

"The stay here was great! The outdoor space and the proximity to the lake can't be beat. I would highly recommend this place and would stay here again."

"Everything was amazing"

"Very nice property with all the amenities. Close proximity to the lake. We hope to return in warmer weather and take advantage of the water and recreational activities. Christine made sure to have a waiver available however we decided not to use canoe or bikes. Clean cozy cottage"

"Property listings and photos, on very few occasions, represent a rental for it's strengths or weaknesses. What I can tell you is that this property is far better than any picture can depict. I write zero reviews, but I was compelled to write this one, not only praising the rental itself, but also the owner/manager, Jennifer. The layout and cleanliness of this camp is unrivaled to any I've ever been in at Pymatuning. I took my brothers-in-law and uncle up to fish for 3 days, and this camp had it...

"We had a great experience at the cottage. The cottage was very clean and the hot tibb was amazing. We would definitely stay here again in the future."

"Nice place to stay, close to the water, and nice activities in the area. For a holiday weekend it was very quit."

"The cabin was very clean and was ready for us when we arrived. However it is tiny and cozy but was fine for a weekend stay. I took my electric skillet and we had our gas grill for cooking. Would stay again but would request one of the larger cabins. Hosts were very nice and very accomodating."

"Exactly as promised."

"The house is in a beautiful setting. The creek that runs along the property is an added bonus. It was a great place to stay. Hoping to return in August."

"This was our first family trip and it was amazing! The cabin was exactly as pictured and just what we were looking for. If you want a cabin in the woods with nothing around this is the place to go! We went to the lake a day and it took about 5/10 minutes to get there! We did have a rainy day as well, but the fire pit is covered so it did not stop the fun! Maggie was great and easy to get ahold. We will be booking again!"

"The location was ideal for boating at Pymatuning, and the accomodations were spacious and quaint, with a peaceful view of a pond and woods."