Agritourism Shelter Island Hotels

"Beautiful, clean, spacious house both inside and outside. Striking distance to all areas of the Hamptons. Highly recommended."

"We celebrated my birthday at this beautiful house. Michael was a great host. Gracious and accommodating. The house is in great taste, comfortable and very well equipped. The boat was lovely and enjoyable. Would definitely rent again."

"Family get together and it was a great space for a large group."

"Clean, plenty of space, open concept kitchen & living room. Kids loved the pond with frogs. Thanks for sharing your home with us!!"

"The location and the property itself was fantastic. Beautiful yard and home. The hosts were so friendly and accommodating. My dog loved the huge yard!"

"Group of lifelong friends celebrating birthdays and just enjoying the area. House was clean and well appointed. Huge and charming. Location is excellent for north fork long island activities, wineries, farms, Greenport village and beaches. We would book this location again."

"We loved our stay at Rachael's home. It truly felt so welcoming and warm. The house was spotless and had a fully stocked kitchen, making it perfect for our family to prepare meals at home. The grounds and the pool were just beautiful. We can't wait to stay again."

"We thoroughly enjoyed our stay in this home. Simple and family friendly. Lovely neighborhood and amazing beach access. The house manager was incredibly responsive and accommodating. I would definitely stay here again."

"Best affordable hotel in Montauk"

"We enjoyed our stay!"

"An amazing stay with our girls!!! Can’t wait to go back!"