Upfront pricingOur total price for your stay includes taxes and fees
Treat yourselfSave 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide with Member Prices
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Top cities in Long Island
Clarence Town
Stella Maris
Galliot Cay
Salt Pond
Deadmans Cay
McKann's Settlement
Seymour's
Check prices for these dates
Our top choices for Long Island secluded hotels
1. Stella Maris Resort Club
Stella Maris Resort Club3.0 star property
Stella Maris
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (61 reviews)
8.8/10
Excellent
(61 reviews)
"Adorable resort very friendly and helpful staff. Enjoyed our stay. Lovely."
"Adorable resort very friendly and helpful staff. Enjoyed our stay. Lovely."
Kimberly
$217 nightly
The price is $237
$237 total
Nov 12 - Nov 13
Total with taxes and fees
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Top Long Island Hotel Reviews
Harbor Breeze Villas
Harbor Breeze VillasClarence Town
10/10 Excellent
I loved every minute of my stay at the villa. The accommodations were excellent, clean and new. We had ocean views within a 5 minute walk to the beach. The property manager, Nancy was helpful and informative. thwte was some construction of another villa nearby which made for some noise but it was overall quiet.
I loved every minute of my stay at the villa. The accommodations were excellent, clean and new. We had ocean views within a 5 minute walk to the beach. The property manager, Nancy was helpful and informative. thwte was some construction of another villa nearby which made for some noise but it was overall quiet.
Anonymous traveler
Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort
Cape Santa Maria Beach ResortGalliot Cay
10/10 Excellent
My wife and I stayed here for our honeymoon and we had a blast! The room was great and the beach was perfect. Lots of activities could be done. We are adventurous and didn't do guided tours. We explored on our own and did a over 6 mile Kayak to monument there.
Overall we had a great time. I would say that we were disappointed at the staff at first. The staff seemed very displeased with the people staying here. As we dug deeper into why with the great bartenders they had there (Kelly and Jay)...
My wife and I stayed here for our honeymoon and we had a blast! The room was great and the beach was perfect. Lots of activities could be done. We are adventurous and didn't do guided tours. We explored on our own and did a over 6 mile Kayak to monument there.
Overall we had a great time. I would say that we were disappointed at the staff at first. The staff seemed very displeased with the people staying here. As we dug deeper into why with the great bartenders they had there (Kelly and Jay)...
Darren
Hideaways Exuma
Hideaways ExumaGeorge Town
10/10 Excellent
Diamond in the ruff !!! we didnt know hat to expect when we arrived but we love this place will stay again. Great staff with a nice restaurant on facility.
Diamond in the ruff !!! we didnt know hat to expect when we arrived but we love this place will stay again. Great staff with a nice restaurant on facility.
Anonymous traveler
Stella Maris Resort Club
Stella Maris Resort ClubStella Maris
10/10 Excellent
Private swim pool carved out of beach coral rock with ocean flowing through. Unbelievably cool!!!! Extremely private. Beach barista makes best mango daiquiri in world- yummy. Walking distance from airport if lightly loaded.
Prices high for everything. Come loaded and have a good time.
Private swim pool carved out of beach coral rock with ocean flowing through. Unbelievably cool!!!! Extremely private. Beach barista makes best mango daiquiri in world- yummy. Walking distance from airport if lightly loaded.
Prices high for everything. Come loaded and have a good time.
Randall
Peace and Plenty Resort
Peace and Plenty ResortGeorge Town
10/10 Excellent
Food is scarce and expensive in Exuma. Bring nuts,snacks in suitcase.$3 can of peanuts at Costco cost $28 in Exuma.Locals are very helpful and have the phone number of all the other locals(ie tour guides, drivers) on speed dial.Everything (conch, coleslaw, BBQ chicken, fries) at Edgewater Restaurant is "to die for", big portions,better value than Fish Fry.Big grocery store next door. Bring lots of cash, especially $5 bills. I'd buy 2 dinners at a time and have it "to go". I put one in the fridge...
Food is scarce and expensive in Exuma. Bring nuts,snacks in suitcase.$3 can of peanuts at Costco cost $28 in Exuma.Locals are very helpful and have the phone number of all the other locals(ie tour guides, drivers) on speed dial.Everything (conch, coleslaw, BBQ chicken, fries) at Edgewater Restaurant is "to die for", big portions,better value than Fish Fry.Big grocery store next door. Bring lots of cash, especially $5 bills. I'd buy 2 dinners at a time and have it "to go". I put one in the fridge...
budget snorkel
Exuma Yacht Club Resort & Marina Limited
Exuma Yacht Club Resort & Marina LimitedGeorge Town
10/10 Excellent
Ms. Flowers was so just sweet host and manager! Ryan was so helpful and even drove us to the airport last minute! Everyone was so cool including Jason the Bartender. The dinner was so fun because the music was awesome and it was right on the water. Great vibes! Recommended to everyone our friend had his yacht on the slip at the marina there. Perfect location! Great room! Thank you all!
Ms. Flowers was so just sweet host and manager! Ryan was so helpful and even drove us to the airport last minute! Everyone was so cool including Jason the Bartender. The dinner was so fun because the music was awesome and it was right on the water. Great vibes! Recommended to everyone our friend had his yacht on the slip at the marina there. Perfect location! Great room! Thank you all!
Lisa
Frequently Asked Questions
Why book your secluded hotel in Long Island with Expedia?
Expedia has excellent deals on secluded hotels in Long Island. But our pocket-friendly prices are just the start of it. You'll find some fantastic stays to select from and useful filters that make it a breeze to find your perfect match. Additionally, you can sign up for Expedia Rewards for free and get access to even bigger discounts and savings.
How can I find cheap secluded hotels in Long Island?
If you're on the lookout for an epic deal on a cheap secluded hotel in Long Island, you'll want to implement several filters into your search. Start with the star rating and budget filters. You can also pick your neighborhood, or use the map to zoom in on a specific part of town and compare hotel rates in one view.