Long Island Quiet Resorts & Hotels from $261

A coastal landscape with a clear blue sea, a sandy beach, and a small island with buildings.

Upfront pricing
Our total price for your stay includes taxes and fees
Treat yourself
Save 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide with Member Prices
Learn about One Key
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check availability on Long Island Quiet Resorts & Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

Next weekend

In two weeks

Our top choices for Long Island secluded hotels

Private beach, free beach shuttle, free beach cabanas, sun loungers

Stella Maris Resort Club

Stella Maris

Kimberly

$239 nightly

Jul 20 - Jul 21

Total with taxes and fees

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

Hideaways Exuma

10/10 Excellent

"We absolutely loved the Hideaways!! We recommend this place to everyone."

Harbor Breeze Villas

8/10 Good

"Pros: clean and spacious room, working A/C, very friendly and helpful staff. Cons: there was no hot water (only lukewarm water). They ran out of in-room coffee. The best thing about this place is the staff. They are very nice and welcoming. There are roosters on the property that serve as alarm clock in the morning. I didn’t mind them at all as I needed to get up early every morning. Overall a pleasant stay."

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

10/10 Excellent

"Breath taking home & wonderful host! Jack and his team made this trip so easy and fun. Before we even landed on the island Jack provided numerous suggestions for shopping, eating & entertainment! The house itself was so comfortable and the space is amazing literally 10 steps from the ocean with a private bea! My family kayaked to Moriah National Park twice! First time we ended up in a secluded bay surrounded by mangroves with green sea turtles swimming around! Once you get to the lazy river which leads to the national park make sure you walk to the ocean side and you'll be greated with a view that'll leave you speechless (it's worth the effort!) The house is a short drive from Tropic of Cancer Beach which is another must see spot. It's hard to put the beauty of that place into words. One evening we had a private chef cook for us based on Jack's recommendation and the meal was exceptional! I can't stress enough how Jack's team made this trip easy to navigate, he even explained how the check in process and flight home would go. We ended up at the restraunt across the street from the airport and had a great meal before the flight! If you want a great Bahamas experience you have to stay at the Bahama Island House! If your're nervous about traveling to a slightly remote island, dont be. Jack is the type of host that will make sure you are taken care of throughout the trip and wants his guests to have a truly wonderful experience!"

Peace and Plenty Resort

10/10 Excellent

"We loved our stay here! Our room was super clean and roomy! The view was beautiful! Front desk attendants were very friendly and helpful as was the entire staff. Boat transfers to the beach club were awesome. The beach club was so much fun. Great location and delicious apps and drinks. Thanks, Andy, for making our day so memorable with our inflatable, food, drinks, kayaking, and island information! You can actually walk or Kayak to Chat N Chill and The Snappy Turtle! There’s also another beach club next door you can check out and we rented a boat from Minns right across the street, which took us to the most beautiful sandbars, turquoise waters, Chat n Chill, and The Coconut Club bar which had great, vacation vibes. There is a quaint little coffee shop right across the street that we visited. Peace and plenty location is amazing because the straw market is right next-door as well as boutique across the street and only a very short walk to the grocery store and liquor store. We went to the fish fry on Friday and tried out a few different spots. We also enjoyed scrumptious food at the hotel restaurant! Loved the steel drum band Friday evening! Great Exumas is gorgeous! Thank you Peace and Plenty for an h forgettable anniversary/birthday celebration!"

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

10/10 Excellent

"I have just returned from Jack’s Island House with 10 college friends celebrating our 60th birthdays. The house was perfect for us! The large screen porch was wonderful for hanging out on, and for the night we had a chef come in. The plunge pool was an amazing way for us to relax at the end of the day. The house was equipped with everything we needed including kayaks, paddle boards and snorkeling equipment. We loved floating to the sandbar, snorkeling under the dock and absorbing all of the beauty. We can’t wait to book our next trip!"

Exuma Yacht Club Resort & Marina Limited

10/10 Excellent

"Ms. Flowers was so just sweet host and manager! Ryan was so helpful and even drove us to the airport last minute! Everyone was so cool including Jason the Bartender. The dinner was so fun because the music was awesome and it was right on the water. Great vibes! Recommended to everyone our friend had his yacht on the slip at the marina there. Perfect location! Great room! Thank you all!"

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Frequently asked questions

Why book your secluded hotel in Long Island with Expedia?

Expedia has excellent deals on secluded hotels in Long Island. But our pocket-friendly prices are just the start of it. You'll find some fantastic stays to select from and useful filters that make it a breeze to find your perfect match. Additionally, you can sign up for Expedia Rewards for free and get access to even bigger discounts and savings.

How can I find cheap secluded hotels in Long Island?

If you're on the lookout for an epic deal on a cheap secluded hotel in Long Island, you'll want to implement several filters into your search. Start with the star rating and budget filters. You can also pick your neighborhood, or use the map to zoom in on a specific part of town and compare hotel rates in one view.

Room 1

Upfront pricing

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check availability on Long Island Quiet Resorts & Hotels

Our top choices for Long Island secluded hotels

Stella Maris Resort Club

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

Hideaways Exuma

HGTV-Featured Beachfront Villa / Steps to Sand / Resort Amenities Included

Exclusive Exuma Beachfront Villa Heated Pool & Ocean views

Pool, Beach, kayaks, great snorkeling, calm side of the island,

Harbor Breeze Villas

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

Peace and Plenty Resort

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

Exuma Yacht Club Resort & Marina Limited

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Frequently asked questions

Quiet Resorts & Hotels in Long Island from $261

Upfront pricing

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check availability on Long Island Quiet Resorts & Hotels

Our top choices for Long Island secluded hotels

Stella Maris Resort Club

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

Hideaways Exuma

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Frequently asked questions