Search Fly Creek Cottages

"My boyfriend and I stayed at the cottage for my graduation weekend. This was truly the perfect getaway to relax and unwind while also being within driving distance of all our friends. The home was spacious, cozy, clean, and stocked with all amenities to feel right at home! Our host communicated with us effectively and ensure our stay was the best it could be! "

"It was a very nice stay! Being in in the quiet mountains but being only 15 minutes from the fields was very convenient and pleasant!"

"We found this cute little hidden gem after a last minute decision to visit Cooperstown with our kids, and we were definitely lucky! This is a small rental but comfy, cozy and enough space for our family of 4. Quiet, beautiful surrounding woods, but not far from amenities and downtown. This home is clean, updated, and the kids loved having the loft as their own space. The owner was very communicative and had the electric fireplace on before we arrived. My kiddos are already asking to go back, and...

"The cabin is very clean, with a nice porch on the lake. Coffee in the morning on the lake was quite nice. There is an outdoor shower which is private and the hot water comes on quickly. The water inside is not potable, and there are obvious signs not to drink it. The hosts provide drinking water. They also provide lots of snacks/coffee/toothbrushes and other amenities you may need. Electric outlets are somewhat sparse but manageable."

"We stay at rentals frequently. This was the nicest one yet! We appreciate all of the original charm this cottage had to offer. The accommodations were family friendly and comfortable. It felt like home away from home. The owners have been quick to respond and delightful to communicate with during our stay. We will be back and recommend to friends and family. "

"The cottage was perfect for our family and a quick ride to Doubleday Field. We enjoyed our stay!"

"An excellent choice if you want a water view while staying in Cooperstown and vicinity. The house was eclectic yet strategically updated with a modern kitchen and baths with a brass fixtures theme throughout the house. The house was equipped with everything we needed and can't imagine what could be lacking for anyone else. Main bedroom view is fantastic, as was our host Michele who was quick to respond to questions and most accommodating when we requested a late checkout. Would not hesitate to...

"My husband and I stayed in this charming property for 3 nights. The property was exactly as described and depicted in the pictures. It is a short drive to downtown Cooperstown and we enjoyed the location spending late afternoons sitting on the deck overlooking the lake. We highly recommend this property!"

"Enjoyed our stay at this beautiful spot on the lake. The cabin was great and almost everything you could need was provided. A great experience and we will definitely visit again !"

"Lovely cottage, beautifully decorated with gorgeous lake views. A special spot on Otsego Lake."

"The Boathouse is located down 67 stairs - which we read about in the description - still a workout, especially when loading in or out. The property was perfect for our family of four. There were lots of bugs on the windows, so we decided to keep them closed at all times. The window AC unit cooled the house enough and fans are provided. The house could use a refresh of furniture and towels. If I went again, I would bring my own towels. The beach towels provided were great. The water is stunning....

"My family and I rented this property while we were in town for a baseball tournament. This property was perfect! It was exactly what we were looking for. We had plenty of space and everything we would need. I would definitely recommend this rental!"

"Wonderful lake house, clean and well stocked!"

"WE WILL BE BACK! GREAT LOCATION, FEW ISSUES BUT WERE HANDLED PROMPTLY."

"My family and I stayed in Cottage #2 for the weekend while our daughter graduated from Oneonta. It was under 20-minutes to get to Oneonta, and the ride was unbelievably picturesque. The cottage was super clean, well-stocked, and had a great porch attached to the cottage. Check-in was easy, and we took advantage of the firepit at night. We had a great weekend!"

"Lovely, relaxing family stay."

"House was exactly as described. Super spacious, well designed, and the big room where everyone can be together was very special was perfect for a group reunion. There were a ton of fun activities and beautiful spots in Cooperstown very close to the house. The host went way above and beyond. They were extremely interesting and interested in understanding our groups needs. Super quick response times. They provided a spreadsheet of recommendations for different activities and grocery...

"HOF, restaurants and bars all super close. Parking is convenient as well."

"Excellent stay house was just as described. Super clean and quiet"