Our stay at Diane's property was overall a memorable experience. We had a good time. The location is breathtaking with beautiful views of the Mackinac bridge and Mackinac island, short distance away from the Mackinac Island Ferry transportation for those hoping to visit that magical place.
Diane was very helpful throughout the process and quickly responded to any questions we had, both via email and calls. Great professionalism and customer service. That lady is a pleasure to deal with!
The only items with an opportunity for improvement would be clearly identifying the lodging (the email indicated to look for Lem's Paradise #2, which in our mind meant the door #2. Since there are multiple buildings and one with multiple doors on it, it took us a few minutes to figure out which building and room was ours). After an entire day of driving, it would help to have more user-friendly signs to figure out without a doubt quickly where to go. This might have been us just being tired from the drive, we ended up asking one other guest on the property for help and he was able to point us in the right direction.
The accommodations were very modest (which is ok), yet the inside greeted us with an unpleasant smell (we needed to open up the windows for a few hours to air the smell out), the couches appeared old and as if they needed a good cleaning (we covered them with sheets we brought from home, which solved the problem), there were dozens of dead flies stuck in the kitchen ceiling lights (one of them the cover was broken), and what appeared as a dirty shower floor prevented us from taking a shower during our stay there. These few items did not change the fact that the property on the outside was magical with beautiful colorful lighting by the building, a comfortable bench by the lake to sit and enjoy the sunsets, plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors overall. These are all fixable - even buying covers for the couches would already improve the first impression, cleaning and replacing the lights in the kitchen, and making sure that the air quality is fresh as the guests enter the room.
Overall - I think we would go back there again if the above improvements were made.