For us, it was a wonderful stay. We loved the history and staying in a beautiful national park. The food and drink in the restaurants was high quality. The gift stores had great merchandise, and prices were reasonable. The Skyline Drive to get to the lodge was amazing. All the staff we met were friendly and helpful. The trails we took were clearly marked and maintained. However, while we loved it, it may not be right for everyone. Don't expect a luxury hotel. Our room was like a cabin, and was a short walk from the lodge. The cabin and the bathroom were clean and had everything we needed, but it is on the old side. The wood walls of the cabin had a musty smell (which a simple air freshener helped with). Also be aware that from the park entrance to the lodge is a 30 minute drive, just something you should be aware of. But what a beautiful drive it is. We really did love it, and have talked about returning.