Find all hotels by Independent in Tilloo Cay from $146

"The house was perfect!! So open but cozy at the same time. The kitchen/living space was exactly what we were looking for. It was very clean and had everything you needed. The beach views were stunning. You can’t beat sitting on the beach taking in the beautiful Bahama blue water or watching the sun set. It was super easy to get to by boat. We docked and it was a very short walk with our bags to the house. Beds were super comfy and bathrooms were clean. Just a heads up you are on the far North side of the island so you definitely need to rent a golf cart or have a boat to get around. The owners were super nice and responsive. They gave amazing recommendations and had answers to any questions you might have about the house and the island. We definitely would recommend and will look for this house if it’s available in the future!!"

"We had a wonderful stay at Poker Face! The house was clean and had amazing views. We loved the porch over looking the water. The owner and caretaker were great to work with. We HIGHLY recommend this rental!"

"Danette was VERY responsive and helpful.Our rental car had a flat tire and she found a place in Cherokee for us to air it up.House was great, I worked in the office using Starlink and took breaks on the beach. The Long Dock is Short Walk! Would definitely stay here again.Thank you Danette!"

"Beautiful Marina. Pools are nice"

"Kitchen was fantastic and Marsh Harbour Concierge took care of provisions.Group of 16 adults, all were very comfortable. House was amazing for a large group!"

"Our host was very informative and made us feel at home "

" Very nice"

"We had an incredible stay! The owner was excellent with communication from start to finish, which made everything smooth and easy. The house itself is amazing—spacious, clean, and beautifully set up for groups. The kitchen, dining room, and living room are all spacious and open, creating a perfect space for everyone to gather and socialize. The bedrooms were very comfortable and much larger than expected. The pool and dock were both fantastic and really added to the experience. Highly recommend this property—we’d definitely stay here again!"

"Great house right on the beach! We had plenty of space for the four families, house was clean and everything worked. (doesn't sound like a big deal, but it is).Kids loved the pool and the beach.We will be back!"