Find 4 Star Hotels in Shelter Island, NY from $195

"Amazing beds "

"Beautiful location. Staff was friendly and helpful. Dining was delicious. Rooms were renovated and spacious "

"Very special: comfortable and relaxing. Gorgeous views. Caring staff."

"N/A"

"Beyond perfect! From the second we got there to the second we left. The hotel was so clean and the staff was so helpful. Not one bad thing to say. I cannot wait to come back. "

"Noise from other guests."

"We stayed in the cottage and it was very well appointed decor wise. Cute common areas where breakfast is. The room could have used another light in the LR and it needed a desk and a better closet. No place to put the luggage and tiny closet. Could be furnished a bit better to accomodate. Overall very nice stay. Tx!"

"Room was clean, comfortable, nicely done. The hotel is close to the beach, walking distance to town. Alex was very nice and helpful, we enjoyed our stay and would definitely come back."

"The best hotel in the Hamptons! Luxury hospitality without pretension. Quiet, simple and the only one worth the price tag. You will pay the same if not more at any other local hotel and receive the worst service. It would be so easy for Roundtree to just rely on the high summer months to make money and rob you because they can, but they don't. The whole team works with an integrity uncommon to the area. Easy walk to everything in town and while they don't have a restaurant or bar they make up...

"The room was large, very nice and clean. "

"beautiful inn with a scenic setting"

"Absolutely the nicest hotel in the area. "

"Absolutely best place to stay in East Hampton! Charming B&B with incredible staff. "

"Staff was very friendly and engaging. Handled all of our needs wonderfully."

"Beautiful property and Michael and Rosealind are some the nicest hosts we have ever encountered. "

"Great hosts"

"quiet and safe, close to everything yet off the 'main' part of the road. bright and airy, loved the room and decor was gorgeous. we were already at the beach, didn't need to see more beach decor. pass to harveys beach was nice, but the beach was gross. breakfast voucher was great, restaurant was quick and delicious"

"We had a wonderful stay. The accommodations and services was outstanding and the property was absolutely beautiful. I have already recommended the hotel to my coworkers and family and will definitely be visiting again! "