Find luxury hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Shelter Island Heightsand its attractions for luxury travelers

Nestled in the serene embrace of Shelter Island Heights, luxury travelers will find a delightful blend of natural beauty and upscale amenities. Begin your exploration at the picturesque Crescent Beach, where soft sands and stunning sunsets invite relaxation and family fun. For those who enjoy the outdoors, the Shelter Island Tennis Club offers top facilities and a chance to mingle with fellow sports enthusiasts. Don’t miss a visit to the historic Shelter Island Library, where you can indulge in a quiet afternoon with a good book or join a community event. The local Vineyards, like the iconic Shelter Island Vineyards, provide an exquisite tasting experience amidst breathtaking views. Finally, for a taste of local gastronomy, the renowned Vine Street Café serves exquisite dishes crafted from fresh, local ingredients. After a day of exploration, retreat to one of the area’s luxury hotels that offer personalized service and stunning views of the bay, making your stay both comfortable and memorable.

Find the best luxury hotels and resorts in Shelter Island Heights

For travelers seeking a luxurious getaway in Shelter Island Heights, these premier hotels offer exceptional amenities and services that ensure a memorable stay.

The Pridwin Hotel

• Why it's great for a luxury retreat: The Pridwin Hotel is an exquisite retreat perfect for luxury travelers, an impressive guest review rating of 9.6. Guests can unwind in the opulent surroundings featuring premium bedding, a full-service spa, and access to a private beach. The hotel’s poolside bar provides a chic atmosphere for relaxing after a day of indulgence.
• Other amenities: In addition to its luxurious offerings, The Pridwin Hotel features a stunning terrace, hydrotherapy treatments, and a range of body treatments to pamper guests. Enjoy complimentary breakfast daily, along with a variety of leisure activities such as billiards, a fitness center, and soothing massages. For those who appreciate exquisite dining, the onsite restaurant offers ocean views, enhancing the overall experience.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.07 miles, Sunset Beach - 0.54 miles, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 2.46 miles

Shelter Island House

• Why it's great for a luxury retreat: Shelter Island House presents a charming yet luxurious stay with a guest review rating of 8.4. This boutique hotel features premium bedding and designer toiletries, ensuring a comfortable experience for travelers. With a lovely poolside bar and concierge service, guests can enjoy personalized attention throughout their stay.
• Other amenities: The hotel's amenities include a beautiful terrace, complimentary breakfast options, and access to nearby beaches for sun-soaked relaxation. Guests can also take advantage of the onsite garden and nearby golf course for outdoor enjoyment. Additional conveniences such as air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and free self-parking elevate the overall guest experience.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.52 miles, Sunset Beach - 0.39 miles, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 1.7 miles

West Neck Guesthouse

• Why it's great for a luxury retreat: West Neck Guesthouse is an inviting choice for luxury travelers, offering a serene atmosphere with a guest review rating of 8.2. The hotel features premium bedding and plush bathrobes, providing guests with a cozy and elegant retreat. With air conditioning and daily housekeeping, comfort and convenience are prioritized throughout your stay.
• Other amenities: Additional features include a kitchenette for those who wish to prepare meals, along with a continental breakfast served daily. Guests can enjoy the tranquil garden surroundings, and complimentary bicycles are available for exploring the nearby scenic areas. The hotel also offers convenient self-parking and is located near the beach, making it an ideal base for relaxation and exploration.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.7 miles, Sunset Beach - 0.57 miles, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 1.35 miles

The Rams Head Inn

• Why it's great for a luxury retreat: The Rams Head Inn offers a luxurious escape with a unique blend of elegance and comfort, reflected in its guest review rating of 7.6. This idyllic hotel features premium bedding, Frette Italian sheets, and a private beach, allowing guests to indulge in relaxation. With champagne service and couples dining options, it’s perfect for romantic getaways.
• Other amenities: In addition to its luxurious accommodations, The Rams Head Inn boasts a terrace, complimentary breakfast, and onsite yoga classes to enhance wellness during your stay. Guests can enjoy a private picnic experience or nearby winery events, ensuring a memorable visit. The hotel also offers self-parking and is surrounded by beautiful gardens, providing a peaceful atmosphere for relaxation.
• Nearby attractions: Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 3.06 miles, Shelter Island Historical Society - 3.82 miles, Gardiner's Bay Country Club - 3.96 miles