Name: Montauk Blue Hotel
Rating: 9.2

Where to stay in Shelter Island

Silver Beach

While Silver Beach might not have many sights to explore, venturing just a little farther will lead you to top things to see and do like Sunset Beach and Crescent Beach.

Coecles Harbor

When in Coecles Harbor, you can plan a visit to Shelter Island Whale's Tail and Gardiner's Bay Country Club, some noteworthy sights in the nearby area.

Menantic Creek

If you're looking for some top things to see and do in Menantic Creek and surrounding area, you can visit Sunset Beach and Shelter Island Whale's Tail.

Hay Beach

Hay Beach might not have many top sights, but Gardiner's Bay Country Club and Greenport Carousel are two attractions nearby that you can check out.

Shorewood

While there might not be top attractions in Shorewood, you can explore the larger area and discover places like Mashomack Preserve and Shelter Island Historical Society.

Montclair Colony

While Montclair Colony isn't home to many top sights, Sunset Beach and Shelter Island Historical Society are some notable places to visit nearby.

See our Where To Stay guide

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

290 Old Montauk Highway Montauk NY

$395 nightly

$452 total

Jan 20 - Jan 21, 2026

Total with taxes and fees

Book a stay at this beach resort in Montauk. Enjoy an outdoor pool, a full-service spa, and 2 restaurants. Popular attractions Hither Woods Preserve and Hither ...

8.2/10 Very Good! (705 reviews)

Good room. Great view! Nice heating system. Friendly staff.

Reviewed on Dec 27, 2025

Water's Edge Resort & Spa

1525 Boston Post Road Westbrook CT

$223 nightly

$256 total

Jan 4 - Jan 5, 2026

Total with taxes and fees

Book a stay at this beach resort in Westbrook. Enjoy free WiFi, free parking, and an outdoor pool. Our guests praise the helpful staff in our reviews. Popular ...

8.8/10 Excellent! (1,000 reviews)

Wonderful hotel with very courteous staff, Water's Edge is top notch in every way

Reviewed on Dec 26, 2025

Montauk Blue Hotel

108 South Emerson Avenue Montauk NY

Book a stay at this beach hotel in Montauk. Enjoy free WiFi, a beach locale, and parking (surcharge). Popular attractions South Edison Beach and Kirk Park Beach ...

9.2/10 Wonderful! (187 reviews)

I always have a 5/5 stay at Montauk Blue.

Reviewed on Nov 19, 2025

Get rates

See all 4,685 properties in Shelter Island

Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Work and Play Special! Extended Stay Discount

Shelter Island NY

Stay at this vacation home in Shelter Island. Enjoy free WiFi, private pools, and a garden. Popular attractions Wades Beach and Mashomack Preserve are located ...

10/10 Exceptional! (53 reviews)

This place is a perfect oasis in an already special environment. The host was wonderful and thoughtful. The cottage was magical and had everything to offer that one could want.

Reviewed on Nov 29, 2025

Montauk Manor

236 Edgemere St. Montauk NY

Stay at this aparthotel in Montauk. Enjoy free WiFi, an outdoor pool, and a 24-hour fitness center. Our guests praise the helpful staff and the clean rooms in ...

9/10 Wonderful! (1,274 reviews)

We gave stayed at Montauk Manor for the holiday for many years. The lobby area is grand and very festive during the holidays. The units are clean and comfortable with amenities that make it easy to eat in if desired. The front desk staff are helpful and friendly and the in house restaurant, Montes, ...

Reviewed on Dec 30, 2025

Cliffside Resort Condominiums

61475 Route 48 (North Road) Greenport NY

Book a stay at this beach aparthotel in Greenport. Enjoy free WiFi, free parking, and an outdoor pool. Popular attractions Railroad Museum of Long Island and ...

8.8/10 Excellent! (249 reviews)

The unit was cute and well-appointed. I would recommend a new refrigerator in the unit, as the freezer door was broken.

Reviewed on Nov 12, 2025

See all properties in Shelter Island

Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Popular places to visit

Gardiner's Bay Country Club

Enjoy a round of golf in Shelter Island at Gardiner's Bay Country Club. Stroll along the area's waterfront or simply enjoy its wineries.

Mashomack Preserve

Explore the great outdoors at Mashomack Preserve, a lovely green space in Shelter Island. Stroll along the beaches or discover the sunsets in this family-friendly area.

Shelter Island Whale's Tail

You can take time to visit Shelter Island Whale's Tail during your travels to Shelter Island. Wander the beaches and waterfront in the area.

Shell Beach

Why not spend a carefree afternoon at Shell Beach during your travels in Shelter Island? Amble around the area's parks or experience its museums.

Havens House

You can spend an afternoon browsing the exhibits at Havens House during your trip to Shelter Island. Stroll along the area's beaches or simply enjoy its wineries.

Menhadden Lane Beach

Why not spend a carefree afternoon at Menhadden Lane Beach during your travels in Shelter Island Heights?

Things to do

The Hamptons, Sag Harbor & Outlet Shopping Day Trip from NYC

$179

per adult

76% of travellers recommend

See all activities in Shelter Island

Shelter Island, NY

Travel Guide

Visit Shelter Island