Amawalk Vacations from $510

The room and grounds were very good

Way too overpriced for what you get! Let’s start with the positives. A magnificent view and a decent bed… The rooms are less than average, with terrible decor, and very noisy, to the point that we could hear clearly the couple next door for the whole night…. just like a cheap motel, except that it costs us almost $800 for the night.

We were looking for a quick overnight in the East End, and the Harpoon House exceeded our expectations in every way. The room was spacious (a suite!) and well-appointed, blending the charm of the original 1648 (!) building with modern amenities and furnishings. We didn't take advantage of the on-property restaurant (formerly Blu Mar), but the menu - by acclaimed chef Rocco DiSpirito - looked excellent, if a bit pricey. Location was ideal, within easy walking distance of all Main Street shops and restaurants, and less than a mile to the beach. And, although things were a bit quieter than in the height of summer - not a bad thing! - we loved being out there for the fall harvest season, with wineries and farms in full swing. All-in-all, our stay at the Harpoon House made for a perfect fall weekend in the Hamptons - highly recommended.

This is my second stay here, and it won’t be the last. Just like last time I especially enjoyed the good water pressure and modern bathroom, and the fact they have washcloths for use, a real plus in my book. I also like their bed linens and pillows. Since I was in a room that faces the street right above the entrance I did occasionally get whiffs of cigarette and “other” smoke, but that’s just circumstantial geography and it didn’t bother me at all. There were a few scuffs and scrapes on the walls and around the AC that needed painting, but nothing structural. The place was clean and I made use of the mini-fridge, microwave and dishes. It was so nice to eat in that way, and it was all spotless. On my check-out day, I had a migraine forming and after speaking with the staff they let me stay an extra 2 hours which let my medication kick in so I could function. I was really grateful and the cleaning staff were so understanding and kind. The office even called me back later that day to make sure I was okay. Definitely booking again in a few weeks.