Buffingtons Island Tours

We loved this stay, the property managers were more than gracious they helped us in the room at 4am and weren’t even upset. We had a wonderful time in a simply gorgeous room, we will definitely be staying with outdoor adventure again!

All phases of this stay was excellent as usual.

This property was a gem, and one of the more affordable options downtown. The decor is gorgeous, from the vintage upholstered furniture to the funky wall art to the retro color choices. I especially liked the common areas and dining room. The bed was comfy and the bathroom was luxurious, with robes, bath salts for the tub, and a light-up magnifying mirror. There weren't drawers or shelves for clothes, which I thought was weird, and the TV was high up and far from the bed. Also, we were upgraded to a suite (thank you!) but it was just one room, albeit generously sized, with no sitting area. It did have a separate tub, though, so maybe their "suite" level is just nicer amenities and a bigger room? Breakfast was basic but nice: just Chobani yogurts , granola or cereal, and little scones. I really loved the onsite bar, it's a dimly lit, romantic space with a good happy hour. Parking was the one downside. You pay $24 for valet parking in a lot that's supposedly surveilled by cameras. But on the weekends, we were told they move the cars to a closer lot, which didn't seem all that secure - no cameras that we could see. What's more, we learned this closer lot is actually free on the weekends so we could have parked there without having to pay the $24 daily fee. Finally, even though we were paying for valet, when we asked for our car on Sunday the lady behind the counter just handed us the keys, forcing us to go get the car ourselves. Aside from the parking, we had a great stay!