Bonnington Vacations from $1,120

To be honest all three stars is for friendly helpful staffs. The room I stayed is zero star.

Everything was perfect. The accommodation is worth it and Billy is a lovely host. Thank you for everything, we'll be back!

Room excellent lovely quiet location but still near city centre etc. staff friendly and helpful. Food excellent.

A very cold room and quite nosy ( pipes, water). It's ok for a couple of nights but not very comfy overall. Good location and staff are friendly. It could do with more attention to detail. It was a bit disappointing.

Pros: I came to Edinburgh for the week of Halloween and found this place to be a really lovely hotel in an old Georgian-style building with beautiful architecture. What sold me on it were the gorgeous library and the full breakfast included in the price. The hotel is located in a quiet neighborhood near Dean Village, about a 20-minute walk into the city center or a 5-10 minute walk to the nearest bus or tram stop. I had an awesome view of the castle from my room's window. Staff were very kind and attentive and offered to carry my bag up for me when the lift was broken, which was a life saver! Cons: Aside from the lift, my only other disappointment was that the full breakfast (ordered from a menu) was only offered for the first few days of my 9-night stay, so I was only able to get the full Scottish breakfast a couple of times before they switched to a regular continental breakfast for the remainder of my time there. Cleaning staff also left someone else's used mug on my nightstand in my room once, which startled me a little since I was staying there alone. I believe they may have been short-staffed due to staff illness, so maybe these things couldn't be helped and are a one-off. Overall, I enjoyed my time staying there!