9/10 Wonderful! (524 reviews)
This was a mixed experience for me. The inn itself is really quaint and cozy, and the staff were absolutely amazing — Dayton at the front desk was wonderful!!! :) Gavin and Erica were so sweet, and the bartender at 56 Tavern was great too. Honestly, the customer service is what stood out the most during my stay.
The downside was my room. It was right above the restaurant and patio, so it was loud — I could hear the patio door opening and closing throughout the day until closing, and it even shook the walls. The hotel was fully booked with two weddings, so switching rooms wasn’t an option. On top of that, the tub stopper didn’t work, the fridge froze my food & bottled waters & the room could have been cleaner (there was dust on the nightstands and a spider web on the ceiling), and the overall quality of the room didn’t feel like it matched the price I paid for it.
So, while I loved the staff and the overall charm of the place, I can’t say I loved my room.
Reviewed on Aug 19, 2025
